As with all descriptions of client encounters, materiel changes are made to protect client confidentiality.
As a licensed professional, I'm required to participate in "continuing education" to keep my license current. After 33 years in the field, I've seen a lot of CE unit offerings, some interesting, lots boring. Some of the best were CEU's I constructed myself to address my own interests, including 2 weeks with Peter Fleming in southern Italy studying Contribution Training (see my website for more) as well as the CEU's received in pursuit of certification with Ross Greene Ph.D., author of The Explosive Child and Lost at School and a 5 year NIMH study recently published proving the efficacy of his method of "Collaborative Proactive Solutions."
I'd seen and heard of the "Explosive Child" book, but had no intent to enter Greene's room early last summer. Getting the CEU's for my license renewal was all I wanted. So I explored the vacation option, you know, the one where professionals get their CEU's and vacation at the same time.
Cape Cod, early summer, the beach, my wife could come, family in New England I could visit. The dates worked. So place and time was set. Now to pick a class that I wanted to learn. It was Ross Greene or some other class that I found to be a bit too touchy feely for my taste, so Greene it was.
I read The Explosive Child on the trip north feeling some obligation to be a responsible student. Well, I read most of it, it was vacation after all. I could read the rest through the week of the conference, which is what I did (having little option, being laid up the entire time with a bad back. It was that or lots of bad TV, so I compromised, reading some and watching some, not lots of bad TV.) When the class began on a high school campus with weathering on its buildings and trees from the thick Cape Cod moisture, the comfortable informality of The Cape was evident, flip flops and t-shirts abounding.
Greene was unassuming - as high end scholars can be. He had been on faculty at Harvard, what else is there to say - or as so many from that most esteemed institution do, to not have to say. Confident, soft spoken, not overbearing like some successful creators of methodologies. Friendly. I was not prepared to be impressed as he rolled out his experience of working with tough kids. I thought he might be one of those guys with a great personality, a lot of charisma that can be so influential but so very hard to replicate. I'd been working with tough kids for decades, so I figured there'd be some reformulation of principles and strategies that have become standard in working with hard kids like: Parents need to be in control and execute a clear behavioral plan centered around "if/then" contingencies such as: "Johnny, IF you clean up your room, THEN you get to go outside and play;" A behavioral plan that is intuitive, scientifically validated by all of my Applied Behavior Analysis colleagues, the bedrock of family systems theory where the parents function as the "executive branch" of the family, setting the structure for the children. How does collaboration fit into this?
I started to pay attention as Green repeatedly focused on the importance of carefully and accurately understanding the child's point of view - not from the parents, or the therapist, or the teacher, but from the kid. I became more intrigued when Greene reinforced over and over the importance of avoiding describing the problem to be discussed in therms of "problem behaviors." He then (had the audacity to) suggest we not present the child with our "theories" about "why" they are behaving in the fashion that's causing us such discontent. Imagine, denying us, the highly educated, very experienced therapists our moment to enlighten the child about their inner motivations. Denying parents who know the kids best - why can't they communicate their expert point of view to their own child?!? Teachers who often spend more time with the child than the parents - they have a real objective point of view to offer the child. All of us adults know what's really going on. So why NOT allow us our moment to "communicate" our observations with the child?
The reason the Collaborative Proactive Solutions model doesn't encourage the sharing of our erudite "theories" with the child is because what we've done, inadvertent as it may be, is overwhelm and intimidate children with our theories. Theories that are often way over the child's cognitive level to understand anyway. Theories that often demean or embarrass the child by pointing out in grand style their lack of judgement and lack of restraint. We haven't left the child behind, we've used shame to attempt to change their behavior. We repeatedly accuse our children of aggression, irresponsibility, bad intent and disregard for parents and siblings welfare. The fact that sometimes the theories may be accurate is besides the point. When the child's being overwhelmed by our power, they are much more likely to respond in a defensive and even hostile fashion, adding more fuel to the fire of the conflict.
Now shame may have some place in child rearing, but, in my view, only when children are very very young and in very proscribed circumstances. We've all seen a small child erupt in tears when they've done something wrong and a parent simply looks at them in a disappointed fashion without saying a word. That's shaming. It can have a proper function, when integrated into the child's emotional package, of self reflection. But the level of shaming that we participate in with our kids in the name of helping them is grossly misguided in my opinion. This is exactly what CPS avoids. By asking children about their behavior in a way that doesn't focus on their behavior (not really as hard as you might think), we lower their defensiveness and heighten their willingness to participate. By dropping our theories, we create a much broader space for the child to tell us their views of the situation. By validating what they say in a reflective, non confronting way, we encourage them to say more. By not pressing them about "why" they did or did not do something (see my post of 3/2/15 "The End of the 'Why' Question") we draw them to tell us what's really on their mind. And isn't that what we really want to know anyway??
Asking the child in a neutral way welcomes participation. Responding in confirming, supportive and non-judgmental ways will garner us much more information much more effectively. Using "reflective listening" (which many parents have learned at some point in college or training), in which we reflect back what the child is telling us in a non judgmental fashion allows space for more communication - and isn't THAT our goal? Remember, parents, listening reflectively isn't agreeing, it's just listening and creating a space for the child to trust and talk.
So I paid more attention to what Greene was saying. And it was made more and more sense as the week continued.
I returned to Atlanta, much more thoughtful than I'd anticipated being after my mostly bedridden week in New England and gave it the old college try. An 11 y/o boy with classic high functioning autism who had come due to some new behavioral concerns. He sat looking at a random spot on the floor, typical for lots of kids on the spectrum who find eye contact difficult. I asked, open ended questions, hoping for a thread of response to which I could "actively listen." It was the longest 25 minutes of any session I've ever had. I was trying to actively listen to shoulder shrugs, to monosyllabic grunts or to the ever present mumbled "I don't know." Slowly, carefuly, I responded. He responded. Repeat. I worked hard; no theory, no behaviors, no "why" questions. This went on for a while and after responding to concerns that actually sounded like a full thought, he looked up - making eye contact - long, lingering eye contact with me for the first time since walking in the door - and after a dramatic pause said with great emotional affect, "Finally, someone's listening to me!" (emphasis not added) Well, that pretty much did it for me - I'd interviewed hundreds of kids on the spectrum without getting a response like that. He's doing great now - really. He still has autism, but we learned enough to put in place enough that provides him the supports he needs.
I was hooked and soon signed up for Greene's advanced certification program.
If you read this blog, you're likely to hear more.
Tuesday, August 25, 2015
Tuesday, July 28, 2015
Marital Jazz - Finding a Couple's Language
As with all postings, materiel changes to any descriptions of clients are made to protect their privacy.
I've been working with Hank and Mary for about a year. They often struggle due to the confluence of a many challenges between them: diabetes, depression, ADHD, and a history of verbal fights that can be pretty sharp. Divorce has been in the air, more, I believe, as a signal of desperation than intent. When they're both calm, they genuinely express their love for one another. And this has gone on for decades.
After one of their tougher disagreements - they didn't speak much for a couple of weeks following a disagreement on how to manage their business - they came in having reached the predictably calm after the storm state in their marital music. The atmosphere between them was soft and caring, unlike the last meeting we had when they were in the middle of their business argument. So I made an observation, drawing on their mutual love of jazz - not that I'm a big jazz guy, my tastes go much more towards classical and classic folk, rock, blues - but I know enough about music and jazz to through around a few comments.
Hank and Mary riff back and forth with one another all the time on themes of her sense of guilt and responsibility - honed at the feet of her critical parents - and his accommodation of her penchant to feel guilty, often depressively so, by criticizing her actions, inactions, or whatever tune she throws to him. One common topic of their conflict is their business - though somewhat surprisingly, given their frequent ups and downs, it's been very successful.
We discussed the subtle ways in which they can go back and forth on the theme of Mary's sense of guilt and the way she over performs in their relationship and business to try to make things better, to try to make Hank happy. And Hank can be somewhat irascible, so she has a broad canvas (if I can mix metaphors) on which to paint. The more Hank's unhappy about this or that issue, expressing his riff on their song, the more Mary will play back with her variation of her wanting to make it right by over functioning, trying to come up with a different, better, novel idea in their business or marital life, rarely to the mollification of Hank and, the improv is on. She struggles to accommodate his dissatisfaction with his topic of the day, and her lack of success in molifying him breeds yet another reprise of the tune of her trying something else, ultimately leading to her fatigue, frequent depression and tears and so often a fight between them.
They've been at this for years, so I don't know if their participation in our discussion using their shared love of jazz might help them see the dance in which they're engaged (mixed artistic metaphor #3 if you're counting). It's a discussion we've had, in one way or another, a few times already, but they have yet to inhibit their repetition of the chorus. Maybe speaking their jazz language will help.
I've been working with Hank and Mary for about a year. They often struggle due to the confluence of a many challenges between them: diabetes, depression, ADHD, and a history of verbal fights that can be pretty sharp. Divorce has been in the air, more, I believe, as a signal of desperation than intent. When they're both calm, they genuinely express their love for one another. And this has gone on for decades.
After one of their tougher disagreements - they didn't speak much for a couple of weeks following a disagreement on how to manage their business - they came in having reached the predictably calm after the storm state in their marital music. The atmosphere between them was soft and caring, unlike the last meeting we had when they were in the middle of their business argument. So I made an observation, drawing on their mutual love of jazz - not that I'm a big jazz guy, my tastes go much more towards classical and classic folk, rock, blues - but I know enough about music and jazz to through around a few comments.
Hank and Mary riff back and forth with one another all the time on themes of her sense of guilt and responsibility - honed at the feet of her critical parents - and his accommodation of her penchant to feel guilty, often depressively so, by criticizing her actions, inactions, or whatever tune she throws to him. One common topic of their conflict is their business - though somewhat surprisingly, given their frequent ups and downs, it's been very successful.
We discussed the subtle ways in which they can go back and forth on the theme of Mary's sense of guilt and the way she over performs in their relationship and business to try to make things better, to try to make Hank happy. And Hank can be somewhat irascible, so she has a broad canvas (if I can mix metaphors) on which to paint. The more Hank's unhappy about this or that issue, expressing his riff on their song, the more Mary will play back with her variation of her wanting to make it right by over functioning, trying to come up with a different, better, novel idea in their business or marital life, rarely to the mollification of Hank and, the improv is on. She struggles to accommodate his dissatisfaction with his topic of the day, and her lack of success in molifying him breeds yet another reprise of the tune of her trying something else, ultimately leading to her fatigue, frequent depression and tears and so often a fight between them.
They've been at this for years, so I don't know if their participation in our discussion using their shared love of jazz might help them see the dance in which they're engaged (mixed artistic metaphor #3 if you're counting). It's a discussion we've had, in one way or another, a few times already, but they have yet to inhibit their repetition of the chorus. Maybe speaking their jazz language will help.
Sunday, July 26, 2015
Standing In His Truth - A Neurotypical Sib's Strength
As with all postings, materiel changes to any descriptions of clients are made to protect their privacy.
Standing in his truth. It's a phrase I always found a bit psychobabble-ish, so I rarely use it. But recently, I sat with an 11 year old boy, Andy, who did so remarkably.
There was, let's say, a difference of opinion between the boy and the child's stepfather about a specific incident. Andy, his sister Crystal, his biological mother and stepfather and were reviewing the incident in my office, the mother, understandably, wanting to create an allegiance, a "united front" with her husband of many years. Crystal is 15 and has high functioning autism and is often a challenge to her parents and step parents, but Andy generally stays out of the fray. Crystal's done a lot of work on a lot of issues and, generally, is doing well.
Now I have to say, I'm overwhelmingly a fan of parents presenting a "united front" when they're dealing with their kids. I've long held that parenting can be at risk of devolving to a game of football where the child "splits" the parents as effectively as a good offensive line can split the defense and scores a goal while parents proceed to fuss at one another about who did what when and why. It's a very well established play that kids call upon given their highly sensitive ability to detect the potential for parental differences. It also can, in the best of circumstances, help parents sharpen their team playing skills - which are often needed when dealing with kids.
But I'm not so sure that Andy was splitting. This is a situation where step dad's depression has become worse we've been working in couple's therapy on the challenges that Crystal brings to the family. Step dad's been using meds to treat his depression, but it's a hard slog, as depression can be, and additionally, Crystal's behavior is indeed a stressor. Men, classically, can become irritable when depressed, which is what I think happened in this case. I've seen stepdad's irritability arise in the office and he has a history of his anger flying a bit off the handle.
When reviewing the incident between Andy and stepdad, the conflict was evident and it looked like a "he said she said" situation, with Andy and step dad on either side of the line and mom wanting to support her husband. Andy impressed me. He related his version of the incident quietly and calmly - remarkably quietly and calmly. Admirably, step dad did not raise his voice or try to leverage his adult role to make Andy submit. He was calm as well, reviewing his view of the incident. Crystal, mostly quiet sat and listened.
Andy's a typically developing kid, the classic "neurotypical" (NT) sib. He and Crystal are shuffled back and forth between the mother's and father's home weekly. There's very little tension between his biological parents and historically, Andy's coped well with the weekly transitions (not as much so for his Crystal), which says a lot for an 11 year old boy with an older sister on the spectrum. Andy is the classic "opposite" of his sister. He is well behaved, responsible about his schoolwork, doing well in scouts, active in sports. Pretty much everything one might want in an 11 year old. Andy has begun to participate in therapy in an extension of the family work mom and stepdad are doing with Crystal.
What impressed me the most was Andy's calm nature when he said his piece. He wasn't defensive, his story didn't waver or change as it was reviewed (and it had been reviewed a lot by the time they brought it to therapy.) He just stated his view of what happened. Strongly, softly. It was quite a moment - and it left mom and step dad a bit befuddled. Later it was step dad who walked his story back a bit, admitting that he's been on edge and struggling with his depression and how to deal with other stressors in his life.
Andy remained calm. It was a bit of a moment, Andy showing his strength of character while mom and step dad re-evaluated what they thought was their united front.
The main thing I took from the exchange was Andy's ability to "stand in his own truth" of what happened. Mom and stepdad will continue to work on their relationship and coping with a teenage girl on the spectrum - which can certainly be challenging to everyone. Stepdad's come out of past depressive slumps OK before.
But Andy - won't he be a force to be reckoned with in the coming years - in very good and exciting ways.
Standing in his truth. It's a phrase I always found a bit psychobabble-ish, so I rarely use it. But recently, I sat with an 11 year old boy, Andy, who did so remarkably.
There was, let's say, a difference of opinion between the boy and the child's stepfather about a specific incident. Andy, his sister Crystal, his biological mother and stepfather and were reviewing the incident in my office, the mother, understandably, wanting to create an allegiance, a "united front" with her husband of many years. Crystal is 15 and has high functioning autism and is often a challenge to her parents and step parents, but Andy generally stays out of the fray. Crystal's done a lot of work on a lot of issues and, generally, is doing well.
Now I have to say, I'm overwhelmingly a fan of parents presenting a "united front" when they're dealing with their kids. I've long held that parenting can be at risk of devolving to a game of football where the child "splits" the parents as effectively as a good offensive line can split the defense and scores a goal while parents proceed to fuss at one another about who did what when and why. It's a very well established play that kids call upon given their highly sensitive ability to detect the potential for parental differences. It also can, in the best of circumstances, help parents sharpen their team playing skills - which are often needed when dealing with kids.
But I'm not so sure that Andy was splitting. This is a situation where step dad's depression has become worse we've been working in couple's therapy on the challenges that Crystal brings to the family. Step dad's been using meds to treat his depression, but it's a hard slog, as depression can be, and additionally, Crystal's behavior is indeed a stressor. Men, classically, can become irritable when depressed, which is what I think happened in this case. I've seen stepdad's irritability arise in the office and he has a history of his anger flying a bit off the handle.
When reviewing the incident between Andy and stepdad, the conflict was evident and it looked like a "he said she said" situation, with Andy and step dad on either side of the line and mom wanting to support her husband. Andy impressed me. He related his version of the incident quietly and calmly - remarkably quietly and calmly. Admirably, step dad did not raise his voice or try to leverage his adult role to make Andy submit. He was calm as well, reviewing his view of the incident. Crystal, mostly quiet sat and listened.
Andy's a typically developing kid, the classic "neurotypical" (NT) sib. He and Crystal are shuffled back and forth between the mother's and father's home weekly. There's very little tension between his biological parents and historically, Andy's coped well with the weekly transitions (not as much so for his Crystal), which says a lot for an 11 year old boy with an older sister on the spectrum. Andy is the classic "opposite" of his sister. He is well behaved, responsible about his schoolwork, doing well in scouts, active in sports. Pretty much everything one might want in an 11 year old. Andy has begun to participate in therapy in an extension of the family work mom and stepdad are doing with Crystal.
What impressed me the most was Andy's calm nature when he said his piece. He wasn't defensive, his story didn't waver or change as it was reviewed (and it had been reviewed a lot by the time they brought it to therapy.) He just stated his view of what happened. Strongly, softly. It was quite a moment - and it left mom and step dad a bit befuddled. Later it was step dad who walked his story back a bit, admitting that he's been on edge and struggling with his depression and how to deal with other stressors in his life.
Andy remained calm. It was a bit of a moment, Andy showing his strength of character while mom and step dad re-evaluated what they thought was their united front.
The main thing I took from the exchange was Andy's ability to "stand in his own truth" of what happened. Mom and stepdad will continue to work on their relationship and coping with a teenage girl on the spectrum - which can certainly be challenging to everyone. Stepdad's come out of past depressive slumps OK before.
But Andy - won't he be a force to be reckoned with in the coming years - in very good and exciting ways.
Monday, July 6, 2015
King Solomon, Hillel and David Burns: If I Am Not For Myself.
As with all postings, materiel changes to any descriptions of clients are made to protect their privacy.
Pretty disparate title, no? King Solomon lived almost 3,000 years ago. Hillel, a Rabbi authored many important opinions in the Jewish Talmud lived about 900 years later. David Burns is a psychiatrist who is still living. What on earth could they have in common?
Kim hs just started HS and has been working hard on dealing with anxiety. Anxiety disorders occurs in 25% of all teens from 13-18 according to the NIMH. That's a lot of kids. So Kim's situation is pretty common. Indeed, I see lots of kids with anxiety.
Kim's dad had, dutifully upon my recommendation, bought her a book about anxiety written by David Burns, the psychiatrist who wrote the seminal book Feeling Good about depression. He's gone on to write about anxiety and panic disorders, and "cognitive behavioral therapy" to which he is a foundational contributor. It's a well documented treatment for anxiety, depression and panic disorders. His books have lots of information, worksheets and the like about anxiety - and Kim and I recently embarked on a detailed discussion about her experience with anxiety as she's begun to go through the book. In the midst of our discussion, I was reminded of comments that seemed so apropos. Historical comments that took us on a millennial trip.
She first observed that if Burns had known so much of this, there had to be a lot of people with these issues to study. She noted that she's likely not as alone as she has feared. I commented reflexively "There's nothing new under the sun," originally stated by King Solomon in Ecclesiastes, commenting upon the pursuits that occupy people's lives. He didn't use the term "cognitive distortions" but, I dare say, would have understood the term in light of his writings about how we develop meaning. Yes, Kim, there's been anxiety since we had to worry about being attacked by saber toothed tigers. Our job is to balance when it makes sense to worry - and when it doesn't.
We then moved on in our discussion about Burns' musings on anxiety and turned the corner into the burden many of us have prioritizing our own needs over the needs of others, and how, if we focus too much on the needs of others, our own needs become neglected. Again, reflexively, I stated Hillel's famous comment from about 2,000 years ago:
"If I'm not for my self, who will be for me? But if I am only for myself, who am I? If not now, when?"
Kim and I discussed that indeed, we are not islands where we never need others, nor do we ignore others' needs. Neither are we able to be a fountain of unlimited giving to others. But we do have to connect and contribute to others. Hillel's goal, if I may be so bold to say, is balance, a skill that many folks with anxiety (and depression) struggle to maintain.
And of Hillel's last statement: "If not now, when?" I think that brings Kim right back to Burns' book. He's quite clear in his books that they are not just for reading. They're for using. Using the tools, the worksheets and the exercises that are outlined to challenge the preconceived conclusions that we have that keep us anxious or depressed. This practice enables learning - in the same way kids play catch with a parent - so they can master the skills involved in throwing and catching the ball. They create muscle memory that sticks with them for a lifetime. The practice with Burns has to do with creating the neural pathways - the neurological equivalent of muscle memory - in order to successfully address the anxiety/depression at hand.
So, Kim is, hopefully, on her way to the path of creating these different strategies to address her anxiety. She's a good kid, a hard worker, and I have faith in her desire to challenge the current "cognitive distortions" that keep her anxious. I was a bit surprised, however, that our discussion of her journey brought us from today, back 2900 years to the days of King Solomon with a short - but meaningful stop some 2000 odd years ago with Hillel.
Pretty disparate title, no? King Solomon lived almost 3,000 years ago. Hillel, a Rabbi authored many important opinions in the Jewish Talmud lived about 900 years later. David Burns is a psychiatrist who is still living. What on earth could they have in common?
Kim hs just started HS and has been working hard on dealing with anxiety. Anxiety disorders occurs in 25% of all teens from 13-18 according to the NIMH. That's a lot of kids. So Kim's situation is pretty common. Indeed, I see lots of kids with anxiety.
Kim's dad had, dutifully upon my recommendation, bought her a book about anxiety written by David Burns, the psychiatrist who wrote the seminal book Feeling Good about depression. He's gone on to write about anxiety and panic disorders, and "cognitive behavioral therapy" to which he is a foundational contributor. It's a well documented treatment for anxiety, depression and panic disorders. His books have lots of information, worksheets and the like about anxiety - and Kim and I recently embarked on a detailed discussion about her experience with anxiety as she's begun to go through the book. In the midst of our discussion, I was reminded of comments that seemed so apropos. Historical comments that took us on a millennial trip.
She first observed that if Burns had known so much of this, there had to be a lot of people with these issues to study. She noted that she's likely not as alone as she has feared. I commented reflexively "There's nothing new under the sun," originally stated by King Solomon in Ecclesiastes, commenting upon the pursuits that occupy people's lives. He didn't use the term "cognitive distortions" but, I dare say, would have understood the term in light of his writings about how we develop meaning. Yes, Kim, there's been anxiety since we had to worry about being attacked by saber toothed tigers. Our job is to balance when it makes sense to worry - and when it doesn't.
We then moved on in our discussion about Burns' musings on anxiety and turned the corner into the burden many of us have prioritizing our own needs over the needs of others, and how, if we focus too much on the needs of others, our own needs become neglected. Again, reflexively, I stated Hillel's famous comment from about 2,000 years ago:
"If I'm not for my self, who will be for me? But if I am only for myself, who am I? If not now, when?"
Kim and I discussed that indeed, we are not islands where we never need others, nor do we ignore others' needs. Neither are we able to be a fountain of unlimited giving to others. But we do have to connect and contribute to others. Hillel's goal, if I may be so bold to say, is balance, a skill that many folks with anxiety (and depression) struggle to maintain.
And of Hillel's last statement: "If not now, when?" I think that brings Kim right back to Burns' book. He's quite clear in his books that they are not just for reading. They're for using. Using the tools, the worksheets and the exercises that are outlined to challenge the preconceived conclusions that we have that keep us anxious or depressed. This practice enables learning - in the same way kids play catch with a parent - so they can master the skills involved in throwing and catching the ball. They create muscle memory that sticks with them for a lifetime. The practice with Burns has to do with creating the neural pathways - the neurological equivalent of muscle memory - in order to successfully address the anxiety/depression at hand.
So, Kim is, hopefully, on her way to the path of creating these different strategies to address her anxiety. She's a good kid, a hard worker, and I have faith in her desire to challenge the current "cognitive distortions" that keep her anxious. I was a bit surprised, however, that our discussion of her journey brought us from today, back 2900 years to the days of King Solomon with a short - but meaningful stop some 2000 odd years ago with Hillel.
Wednesday, June 10, 2015
A Look of Shame: Learning Disability Hints and IDEA
As with all of my postings, materiel changes in descriptions of clients are made to protect their identity.
Speaking with a typically developing teen and his dad (mom works late), we reviewed his end of year grades. With a bit of a sheepish smile he said he had C's and B's. Now I know this kid, he's not lacking smarts. His parents are very successful in their jointly owned business. And while genetics aren't everything, they do need to be considered. Thus my hunch that the reason, we'll call him Harry, the reason Harry didn't perform better academically was not due to his lack of potential.
So I inquired how much he studies and does homework at home. Again, with his sheepish, engaging smile "about 15 minutes" slid out of his mouth. Nightly? No, Per week. "So" I said,"That's about zero minutes per night, if we round it out." We all smiled, laughed a bit, and as I explored his lack of persistence in his work ethic (an ethic he has for many other activities, some of them pretty technical) I suspected that he might be having troubles reading.
He admitted that he did mentioning that the only way he could get through his English lit class this year was to listen to the book on CD while reading it. Hmmmm, another data point. A classic compensation for someone with a learning disability. I asked more: has reading always been hard? Yes. Do you read for pleasure? No. So I looked at dad and asked: Do either you or your wife have any history of challenges with reading? And then it happened.
Now this dad is as gregarious a guy as you'll meet. As I mentioned, he's quite successful, and his personality has clearly helped in his career. We often banter, joke and he's never caught off guard. Dad's look was one I wish I could have photographed. Here's this man who I know to be worth many millions of dollars with a business that's likely worth many millions more. And just at the moment I asked if he or his wife had difficulty learning he looked like a 4 year old kid who was caught with his hand in the cookie jar. He was without words. His chin looked like it was going to quiver. The tears of shame were close. He looked so sad, like he needed to sit on someone's lap for comfort. Finally he squeezed out, shamefully, quietly, "Yes, I've never read well."
I reviewed with him, you went to college, right? Yes, he replied, a couple of years at a technical college. He did well in the tech classes as they demanded less reading. I worked as hard as I could to normalize his challenges, and went on my LD schpiel, one that I and other professionals have given a zillion times. It's about how LD's were very common and have nothing to do with intelligence - as evidenced by dad's broad knowledge about a plethora of topics. I went on to add that LD's were often found in family trees, so the hypothesis was that Harry had an LD. I asked how had Harry made it so far without being screened or tested for an LD? Dad said that mom had been working with him, supporting him, reading with and to him, which gave him enough to make it through, so far, into high school.
So we went on to discuss psychological testing as the proper method to determine if there indeed was a LD, or possibly some other reason the reading was so difficult, but I told them I'd bet most of the farm that the son was walking in the steps of the father re: his reading challenges. I continued my LD schpiel: if Harry has an LD, the school was obligated to provide accommodations as needed or recommended from the psychologist. For the second time dad was caught up short. He hesitated, awkwardly - started to speak..."what about" but couldn't finish the sentence. I wondered if he was worried about Harry's being "the SPED kid" (special ed) and assured him that there was no stigma involved, that these type of accommodations were common these days due to IDEA and that the number of IEP's out there were too numerous to count. I stated, for emphasis as I always do when discussing these things, that IDEA is federal law (accent on "federal") assuring accommodations for LD's. Dad was shocked. Really? It's law? I assured him that indeed, it has been the law for 25 years. Dad was even more shocked. So I gave him the info to read on line - he said he could read slowly.
I have fair confidence that Harry's parents will get him tested. He learns great if he can listen to the materiel, which is a great way to compensate, and while discussing that many textbooks were available to be listened to - the son perked up saying he could certainly do that!
I felt great at the end of the session, assessing, educating, advocating, but as I thought of it further, I didn't feel so great. What remains with me was the look of shame on dad's face, followed by his shock that schools were obligated to accommodate LD's. Kids with LD's no longer need to be ashamed like Harry's dad clearly was. We've come a long way, I assured dad, from the time he was a kid. And despite the great awareness about learning differences, as a colleague of mine re-frames LD's, this mom and dad didn't really know about the strides of progress that have been made.
But I wonder, where were the schools in seeing Harry's struggles? Dad's struggles were written all over his face. Thirty five years later, Harry's schools certainly should have noticed his difficulty reading! How could educators have missed this over the course of so many years? That's where the real shame lies.
Speaking with a typically developing teen and his dad (mom works late), we reviewed his end of year grades. With a bit of a sheepish smile he said he had C's and B's. Now I know this kid, he's not lacking smarts. His parents are very successful in their jointly owned business. And while genetics aren't everything, they do need to be considered. Thus my hunch that the reason, we'll call him Harry, the reason Harry didn't perform better academically was not due to his lack of potential.
So I inquired how much he studies and does homework at home. Again, with his sheepish, engaging smile "about 15 minutes" slid out of his mouth. Nightly? No, Per week. "So" I said,"That's about zero minutes per night, if we round it out." We all smiled, laughed a bit, and as I explored his lack of persistence in his work ethic (an ethic he has for many other activities, some of them pretty technical) I suspected that he might be having troubles reading.
He admitted that he did mentioning that the only way he could get through his English lit class this year was to listen to the book on CD while reading it. Hmmmm, another data point. A classic compensation for someone with a learning disability. I asked more: has reading always been hard? Yes. Do you read for pleasure? No. So I looked at dad and asked: Do either you or your wife have any history of challenges with reading? And then it happened.
Now this dad is as gregarious a guy as you'll meet. As I mentioned, he's quite successful, and his personality has clearly helped in his career. We often banter, joke and he's never caught off guard. Dad's look was one I wish I could have photographed. Here's this man who I know to be worth many millions of dollars with a business that's likely worth many millions more. And just at the moment I asked if he or his wife had difficulty learning he looked like a 4 year old kid who was caught with his hand in the cookie jar. He was without words. His chin looked like it was going to quiver. The tears of shame were close. He looked so sad, like he needed to sit on someone's lap for comfort. Finally he squeezed out, shamefully, quietly, "Yes, I've never read well."
I reviewed with him, you went to college, right? Yes, he replied, a couple of years at a technical college. He did well in the tech classes as they demanded less reading. I worked as hard as I could to normalize his challenges, and went on my LD schpiel, one that I and other professionals have given a zillion times. It's about how LD's were very common and have nothing to do with intelligence - as evidenced by dad's broad knowledge about a plethora of topics. I went on to add that LD's were often found in family trees, so the hypothesis was that Harry had an LD. I asked how had Harry made it so far without being screened or tested for an LD? Dad said that mom had been working with him, supporting him, reading with and to him, which gave him enough to make it through, so far, into high school.
So we went on to discuss psychological testing as the proper method to determine if there indeed was a LD, or possibly some other reason the reading was so difficult, but I told them I'd bet most of the farm that the son was walking in the steps of the father re: his reading challenges. I continued my LD schpiel: if Harry has an LD, the school was obligated to provide accommodations as needed or recommended from the psychologist. For the second time dad was caught up short. He hesitated, awkwardly - started to speak..."what about" but couldn't finish the sentence. I wondered if he was worried about Harry's being "the SPED kid" (special ed) and assured him that there was no stigma involved, that these type of accommodations were common these days due to IDEA and that the number of IEP's out there were too numerous to count. I stated, for emphasis as I always do when discussing these things, that IDEA is federal law (accent on "federal") assuring accommodations for LD's. Dad was shocked. Really? It's law? I assured him that indeed, it has been the law for 25 years. Dad was even more shocked. So I gave him the info to read on line - he said he could read slowly.
I have fair confidence that Harry's parents will get him tested. He learns great if he can listen to the materiel, which is a great way to compensate, and while discussing that many textbooks were available to be listened to - the son perked up saying he could certainly do that!
I felt great at the end of the session, assessing, educating, advocating, but as I thought of it further, I didn't feel so great. What remains with me was the look of shame on dad's face, followed by his shock that schools were obligated to accommodate LD's. Kids with LD's no longer need to be ashamed like Harry's dad clearly was. We've come a long way, I assured dad, from the time he was a kid. And despite the great awareness about learning differences, as a colleague of mine re-frames LD's, this mom and dad didn't really know about the strides of progress that have been made.
But I wonder, where were the schools in seeing Harry's struggles? Dad's struggles were written all over his face. Thirty five years later, Harry's schools certainly should have noticed his difficulty reading! How could educators have missed this over the course of so many years? That's where the real shame lies.
Sunday, June 7, 2015
Two Kids, Same Assessment: Work and Behavior
As with all of my postings, materiel changes in descriptions of clients are made to protect their identity.
I'm seeing a number of kids right now who flunk my Work and Behavior assessment. It's a bit simple: Kids have two main tasks in life; Work (which for them is school) and Behavior (meaning that their behavior needs to be within the bell curve of acceptable for their family and school.) Lets look at two of them, Mike and Charlie.
Mike is a very easy kid to like. He's very smart, has a sense of humor that's great (mostly meaning he laughs at my admittedly obtuse jokes) and he cares, a lot. He lives with his mom, who's great. She's on top of everything and as a single mom deserves awards for caring for Mike and his sister so well.
It's a bit of a different situation at dad's. Dad's home is, shall we say, challenged. His girlfriend is there, on and off. Dad's sister lives there, (works part time), as does her daughter, and her daughter's 4 year old daughter. Dad openly states to Mike that his obligations to care for Mike are just that, obligations. The court order said he was in charge every other week, and he's fulfilling that obligation. Minimally. He openly states he doesn't have to like Mike, refers to Mike with a variety of epithets that aren't really fit for a family forum like this. Maybe he's trying to be funny, but he's hurting Mike. Deeply. And Mike, good kid that he is, is loyal to his dad. He's old enough that he could just stop going, but he loves his dad and is stuck on not wanting to impair that relationship further.
Mike and I have not yet had the talk that we will soon have regarding the difficulty growing up and realizing that parents are human. Sometimes painfully so, as in Mike's case. Sometimes we have to just face our parents' faults, as painful as it is.
But the issue here is assessment. Assessing Mike is a bit easy, as he's such a good kid. No behavior problems at mom's or dad's (though dad, who won't come to therapy, I'm sure would find fault with his son.) Mike flunked most of his classes this year. And that may be the best thing for my relationship with him. As I'm trying to get Mike to see that his relationship with his dad is hurtful, the reflection of that is his grades. Now as I said, Mike's a really smart guy. Last year his grades rocked. This year they tanked. I don't know what happened between last year and this year, except that he's in high school now which might be a piece of it, as the classes indeed are harder. But with the every other week custody thing (I don't usually see it working so well for the kids, but the parents get exactly what they want), and the harshness at dad's home, the semi-chaotic nature of dad's house, with his aunt coming and going, his cousin coming and going, and Mike being the back up baby sitter for the 4 year old, without warning or compensation, Mike's only response when he's at his dad's is to spend as much time in his room alone as possible. The evidence is clear: he's not able to do his schoolwork the way he needs. It's a mess. Hopefully, Mike will have the strength to take care of himself first. I'm actually optimistic.
Charlie is a different case all together. He has great grades, even as he struggles with his parents' somewhat restricted expectations of him, and he responds not so nicely. Charlie's not the sensitive artistic kid his parents, both artsy folks, really saw him becoming. His time at piano lessons was, lets say, not terribly productive. (Dad is a very accomplished pianist - when he's not doing really well in the advertising business.) Charlie would much rather be playing lacrosse, or run on the cross country team, excelling in both. Again, how to assess: behavior? Fine. Work? Not so much.
Charlie will quickly yell and scream at his parents when angry. His anger is the kind that comes from depression - irritability is a classic (and often under recognized) symptom of depression, and boy can he be irritable. It sometimes doesn't take much and he and I have been meeting to understand more of what triggers his irratibilty. Fortunately, between his medications and the Collaborative Proactive Solutions model (see my other posts and posts to come on Ross Greene's model) he's doing better. Much better, actually, and it's lovely to see.
Charlie was pleasantly easy to engage when it came to collaborative problem solving. His dad did great at adopting the strategies, (his mom's been a bit more shy at trying it) and Charlie quickly and easily engages with them when using the method. Charlie knew that his behavior at home was a problem. He just didn't feel like his parents heard him well enough, which is what Greene's model helps with so well.
Now it's not over for Charlie, I'm sure there's more challenges to come, but he knows, and his parents certainly know, that good grades are not the ballgame. He also needs to be able to manage his behavior. Mike also needs help, but it's with his work (school) not his "behavior" per se.
I often tell parents and teens that the way I assess kids is their work and their behavior. It's not a perfect model, but it sure works a lot.
I'm seeing a number of kids right now who flunk my Work and Behavior assessment. It's a bit simple: Kids have two main tasks in life; Work (which for them is school) and Behavior (meaning that their behavior needs to be within the bell curve of acceptable for their family and school.) Lets look at two of them, Mike and Charlie.
Mike is a very easy kid to like. He's very smart, has a sense of humor that's great (mostly meaning he laughs at my admittedly obtuse jokes) and he cares, a lot. He lives with his mom, who's great. She's on top of everything and as a single mom deserves awards for caring for Mike and his sister so well.
It's a bit of a different situation at dad's. Dad's home is, shall we say, challenged. His girlfriend is there, on and off. Dad's sister lives there, (works part time), as does her daughter, and her daughter's 4 year old daughter. Dad openly states to Mike that his obligations to care for Mike are just that, obligations. The court order said he was in charge every other week, and he's fulfilling that obligation. Minimally. He openly states he doesn't have to like Mike, refers to Mike with a variety of epithets that aren't really fit for a family forum like this. Maybe he's trying to be funny, but he's hurting Mike. Deeply. And Mike, good kid that he is, is loyal to his dad. He's old enough that he could just stop going, but he loves his dad and is stuck on not wanting to impair that relationship further.
Mike and I have not yet had the talk that we will soon have regarding the difficulty growing up and realizing that parents are human. Sometimes painfully so, as in Mike's case. Sometimes we have to just face our parents' faults, as painful as it is.
But the issue here is assessment. Assessing Mike is a bit easy, as he's such a good kid. No behavior problems at mom's or dad's (though dad, who won't come to therapy, I'm sure would find fault with his son.) Mike flunked most of his classes this year. And that may be the best thing for my relationship with him. As I'm trying to get Mike to see that his relationship with his dad is hurtful, the reflection of that is his grades. Now as I said, Mike's a really smart guy. Last year his grades rocked. This year they tanked. I don't know what happened between last year and this year, except that he's in high school now which might be a piece of it, as the classes indeed are harder. But with the every other week custody thing (I don't usually see it working so well for the kids, but the parents get exactly what they want), and the harshness at dad's home, the semi-chaotic nature of dad's house, with his aunt coming and going, his cousin coming and going, and Mike being the back up baby sitter for the 4 year old, without warning or compensation, Mike's only response when he's at his dad's is to spend as much time in his room alone as possible. The evidence is clear: he's not able to do his schoolwork the way he needs. It's a mess. Hopefully, Mike will have the strength to take care of himself first. I'm actually optimistic.
Charlie is a different case all together. He has great grades, even as he struggles with his parents' somewhat restricted expectations of him, and he responds not so nicely. Charlie's not the sensitive artistic kid his parents, both artsy folks, really saw him becoming. His time at piano lessons was, lets say, not terribly productive. (Dad is a very accomplished pianist - when he's not doing really well in the advertising business.) Charlie would much rather be playing lacrosse, or run on the cross country team, excelling in both. Again, how to assess: behavior? Fine. Work? Not so much.
Charlie will quickly yell and scream at his parents when angry. His anger is the kind that comes from depression - irritability is a classic (and often under recognized) symptom of depression, and boy can he be irritable. It sometimes doesn't take much and he and I have been meeting to understand more of what triggers his irratibilty. Fortunately, between his medications and the Collaborative Proactive Solutions model (see my other posts and posts to come on Ross Greene's model) he's doing better. Much better, actually, and it's lovely to see.
Charlie was pleasantly easy to engage when it came to collaborative problem solving. His dad did great at adopting the strategies, (his mom's been a bit more shy at trying it) and Charlie quickly and easily engages with them when using the method. Charlie knew that his behavior at home was a problem. He just didn't feel like his parents heard him well enough, which is what Greene's model helps with so well.
Now it's not over for Charlie, I'm sure there's more challenges to come, but he knows, and his parents certainly know, that good grades are not the ballgame. He also needs to be able to manage his behavior. Mike also needs help, but it's with his work (school) not his "behavior" per se.
I often tell parents and teens that the way I assess kids is their work and their behavior. It's not a perfect model, but it sure works a lot.
Thursday, May 14, 2015
Old Enough to do Stupid Things
As with all of my postings, materiel changes in descriptions of clients are made to protect their identity.
I've been seeing this really nice, smart kid from a really good family - his story is pretty irrelevant except for one thing he said recently. We were discussing that as he has been getting older (late teens) his social life has gone the way that is so common. He's smoked marijuana once or twice but hasn't really used alcohol and while he's still a virgin, he's been romantically involved and has engaged in what we might once have referred to as "heavy petting." I'm sure he's interested in more when he has the opportunity. We were discussing his life and some of the stress he's been under and I suggested that until he was stable for a bit longer, that he remain cautious about using substances and becoming sexually active. I quickly qualified to him that I wasn't endorsing or condemning these activities, rather I was acknowledging the realities of our society today.
According to the US National Library of Medicine National Institute of Health, as of March 2014, fully 34% of our youth under the age of 16 reported use of alcohol and marijuana. 21% of high school seniors are current users of marijuana according to the National Institute of Drug Addiction. As we know from even a cursory review of the news, the brain doesn't really stop developing until somewhere in the early 20's. So 34% of our kids are using psychoactive addictive substances when their brains are no more than 75% mature. Not surprisingly, the study concludes that kids who have these habits are those with the higher rates of substance abuse problems. It didn't say, but I'm supposing that the numbers of kids with mental health issues in this population is also high. The CDC reports that over 12% of kids over the age of 12 have used either illegal drugs or have used pharmaceuticals for recreation in the past month. Of high schoolers, CDC reports that 47% have had sexual intercourse, 34% having had intercourse in the last 3 months and of that number, almost 15% didn't use a condom. 15% of high schoolers have had sex with 4 or more partners. These are sobering numbers.
I recently spoke with a mom (dad's not in the picture) about some very troubling behaviors her teen daughter was engaged in - serious depression coupled with serious drug and alcohol use and casual sexual activity. I flatly expressed my concern to mom that her child's emotional stability seemed quite inconsistent with the ability to manage alcohol drug use and sexual activity. Mom's response surprised me, to say the least. She said "She's in high school - isn't that what she's supposed to be doing?" Gently as I could, I clarified why a young teen with mental health issues is not "supposed" to drink, smoke pot and have sex. I'm not sure if it got through.
Which brings us back to the young man who used the phrase that is the title of this piece. He's had some challenges - that are greatly outweighed by his strengths. He's smart, does quite well in school and has great parental support. He understands that getting high, drunk and having sex are, in his words "stupid" things for someone of his station. But these are things that most all adults have done. The National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism reports that almost 87% of adults have used alcohol. A Gallup poll reports that 38% of Americans have used marijuana. And as only 4% of Americans die as virgins, most all of us, sooner or later, have been sexually active. So virtually all of us engage in these activities, some of us have engaged in many of them.
So, when are we old enough to begin to do stupid things? I don't know. It's obviously dependent on many variables. And I'm not saying that responsible use of psychoactive substances or responsible sexual behavior is bad or good. Sexual activity is a developmentally (not to mention anthropologically and biologically) normal behavior. The use of alcohol (and in some cultures other psychoactive substances) is a part of many religious and social norms. What I do know is that mixing these emotionally demanding behaviors (that statistically, most all of us do or have done) is a bad mix with a brain that's underdeveloped. It's worse for a kid who's experiencing mental health issues. I'm also pretty sure that the kid who questioned when he would be "old enough to do stupid things" has a good shot at success. After all, if he's smart enough to ask the question, he's already showing some wisdom.
I've been seeing this really nice, smart kid from a really good family - his story is pretty irrelevant except for one thing he said recently. We were discussing that as he has been getting older (late teens) his social life has gone the way that is so common. He's smoked marijuana once or twice but hasn't really used alcohol and while he's still a virgin, he's been romantically involved and has engaged in what we might once have referred to as "heavy petting." I'm sure he's interested in more when he has the opportunity. We were discussing his life and some of the stress he's been under and I suggested that until he was stable for a bit longer, that he remain cautious about using substances and becoming sexually active. I quickly qualified to him that I wasn't endorsing or condemning these activities, rather I was acknowledging the realities of our society today.
According to the US National Library of Medicine National Institute of Health, as of March 2014, fully 34% of our youth under the age of 16 reported use of alcohol and marijuana. 21% of high school seniors are current users of marijuana according to the National Institute of Drug Addiction. As we know from even a cursory review of the news, the brain doesn't really stop developing until somewhere in the early 20's. So 34% of our kids are using psychoactive addictive substances when their brains are no more than 75% mature. Not surprisingly, the study concludes that kids who have these habits are those with the higher rates of substance abuse problems. It didn't say, but I'm supposing that the numbers of kids with mental health issues in this population is also high. The CDC reports that over 12% of kids over the age of 12 have used either illegal drugs or have used pharmaceuticals for recreation in the past month. Of high schoolers, CDC reports that 47% have had sexual intercourse, 34% having had intercourse in the last 3 months and of that number, almost 15% didn't use a condom. 15% of high schoolers have had sex with 4 or more partners. These are sobering numbers.
I recently spoke with a mom (dad's not in the picture) about some very troubling behaviors her teen daughter was engaged in - serious depression coupled with serious drug and alcohol use and casual sexual activity. I flatly expressed my concern to mom that her child's emotional stability seemed quite inconsistent with the ability to manage alcohol drug use and sexual activity. Mom's response surprised me, to say the least. She said "She's in high school - isn't that what she's supposed to be doing?" Gently as I could, I clarified why a young teen with mental health issues is not "supposed" to drink, smoke pot and have sex. I'm not sure if it got through.
Which brings us back to the young man who used the phrase that is the title of this piece. He's had some challenges - that are greatly outweighed by his strengths. He's smart, does quite well in school and has great parental support. He understands that getting high, drunk and having sex are, in his words "stupid" things for someone of his station. But these are things that most all adults have done. The National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism reports that almost 87% of adults have used alcohol. A Gallup poll reports that 38% of Americans have used marijuana. And as only 4% of Americans die as virgins, most all of us, sooner or later, have been sexually active. So virtually all of us engage in these activities, some of us have engaged in many of them.
So, when are we old enough to begin to do stupid things? I don't know. It's obviously dependent on many variables. And I'm not saying that responsible use of psychoactive substances or responsible sexual behavior is bad or good. Sexual activity is a developmentally (not to mention anthropologically and biologically) normal behavior. The use of alcohol (and in some cultures other psychoactive substances) is a part of many religious and social norms. What I do know is that mixing these emotionally demanding behaviors (that statistically, most all of us do or have done) is a bad mix with a brain that's underdeveloped. It's worse for a kid who's experiencing mental health issues. I'm also pretty sure that the kid who questioned when he would be "old enough to do stupid things" has a good shot at success. After all, if he's smart enough to ask the question, he's already showing some wisdom.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)