As with all of my postings, materiel changes in descriptions of clients are made to protect their identity.
I'm seeing a number of kids right now who flunk my Work and Behavior assessment. It's a bit simple: Kids have two main tasks in life; Work (which for them is school) and Behavior (meaning that their behavior needs to be within the bell curve of acceptable for their family and school.) Lets look at two of them, Mike and Charlie.
Mike is a very easy kid to like. He's very smart, has a sense of humor that's great (mostly meaning he laughs at my admittedly obtuse jokes) and he cares, a lot. He lives with his mom, who's great. She's on top of everything and as a single mom deserves awards for caring for Mike and his sister so well.
It's a bit of a different situation at dad's. Dad's home is, shall we say, challenged. His girlfriend is there, on and off. Dad's sister lives there, (works part time), as does her daughter, and her daughter's 4 year old daughter. Dad openly states to Mike that his obligations to care for Mike are just that, obligations. The court order said he was in charge every other week, and he's fulfilling that obligation. Minimally. He openly states he doesn't have to like Mike, refers to Mike with a variety of epithets that aren't really fit for a family forum like this. Maybe he's trying to be funny, but he's hurting Mike. Deeply. And Mike, good kid that he is, is loyal to his dad. He's old enough that he could just stop going, but he loves his dad and is stuck on not wanting to impair that relationship further.
Mike and I have not yet had the talk that we will soon have regarding the difficulty growing up and realizing that parents are human. Sometimes painfully so, as in Mike's case. Sometimes we have to just face our parents' faults, as painful as it is.
But the issue here is assessment. Assessing Mike is a bit easy, as he's such a good kid. No behavior problems at mom's or dad's (though dad, who won't come to therapy, I'm sure would find fault with his son.) Mike flunked most of his classes this year. And that may be the best thing for my relationship with him. As I'm trying to get Mike to see that his relationship with his dad is hurtful, the reflection of that is his grades. Now as I said, Mike's a really smart guy. Last year his grades rocked. This year they tanked. I don't know what happened between last year and this year, except that he's in high school now which might be a piece of it, as the classes indeed are harder. But with the every other week custody thing (I don't usually see it working so well for the kids, but the parents get exactly what they want), and the harshness at dad's home, the semi-chaotic nature of dad's house, with his aunt coming and going, his cousin coming and going, and Mike being the back up baby sitter for the 4 year old, without warning or compensation, Mike's only response when he's at his dad's is to spend as much time in his room alone as possible. The evidence is clear: he's not able to do his schoolwork the way he needs. It's a mess. Hopefully, Mike will have the strength to take care of himself first. I'm actually optimistic.
Charlie is a different case all together. He has great grades, even as he struggles with his parents' somewhat restricted expectations of him, and he responds not so nicely. Charlie's not the sensitive artistic kid his parents, both artsy folks, really saw him becoming. His time at piano lessons was, lets say, not terribly productive. (Dad is a very accomplished pianist - when he's not doing really well in the advertising business.) Charlie would much rather be playing lacrosse, or run on the cross country team, excelling in both. Again, how to assess: behavior? Fine. Work? Not so much.
Charlie will quickly yell and scream at his parents when angry. His anger is the kind that comes from depression - irritability is a classic (and often under recognized) symptom of depression, and boy can he be irritable. It sometimes doesn't take much and he and I have been meeting to understand more of what triggers his irratibilty. Fortunately, between his medications and the Collaborative Proactive Solutions model (see my other posts and posts to come on Ross Greene's model) he's doing better. Much better, actually, and it's lovely to see.
Charlie was pleasantly easy to engage when it came to collaborative problem solving. His dad did great at adopting the strategies, (his mom's been a bit more shy at trying it) and Charlie quickly and easily engages with them when using the method. Charlie knew that his behavior at home was a problem. He just didn't feel like his parents heard him well enough, which is what Greene's model helps with so well.
Now it's not over for Charlie, I'm sure there's more challenges to come, but he knows, and his parents certainly know, that good grades are not the ballgame. He also needs to be able to manage his behavior. Mike also needs help, but it's with his work (school) not his "behavior" per se.
I often tell parents and teens that the way I assess kids is their work and their behavior. It's not a perfect model, but it sure works a lot.
Sunday, June 7, 2015
Thursday, May 14, 2015
Old Enough to do Stupid Things
As with all of my postings, materiel changes in descriptions of clients are made to protect their identity.
I've been seeing this really nice, smart kid from a really good family - his story is pretty irrelevant except for one thing he said recently. We were discussing that as he has been getting older (late teens) his social life has gone the way that is so common. He's smoked marijuana once or twice but hasn't really used alcohol and while he's still a virgin, he's been romantically involved and has engaged in what we might once have referred to as "heavy petting." I'm sure he's interested in more when he has the opportunity. We were discussing his life and some of the stress he's been under and I suggested that until he was stable for a bit longer, that he remain cautious about using substances and becoming sexually active. I quickly qualified to him that I wasn't endorsing or condemning these activities, rather I was acknowledging the realities of our society today.
According to the US National Library of Medicine National Institute of Health, as of March 2014, fully 34% of our youth under the age of 16 reported use of alcohol and marijuana. 21% of high school seniors are current users of marijuana according to the National Institute of Drug Addiction. As we know from even a cursory review of the news, the brain doesn't really stop developing until somewhere in the early 20's. So 34% of our kids are using psychoactive addictive substances when their brains are no more than 75% mature. Not surprisingly, the study concludes that kids who have these habits are those with the higher rates of substance abuse problems. It didn't say, but I'm supposing that the numbers of kids with mental health issues in this population is also high. The CDC reports that over 12% of kids over the age of 12 have used either illegal drugs or have used pharmaceuticals for recreation in the past month. Of high schoolers, CDC reports that 47% have had sexual intercourse, 34% having had intercourse in the last 3 months and of that number, almost 15% didn't use a condom. 15% of high schoolers have had sex with 4 or more partners. These are sobering numbers.
I recently spoke with a mom (dad's not in the picture) about some very troubling behaviors her teen daughter was engaged in - serious depression coupled with serious drug and alcohol use and casual sexual activity. I flatly expressed my concern to mom that her child's emotional stability seemed quite inconsistent with the ability to manage alcohol drug use and sexual activity. Mom's response surprised me, to say the least. She said "She's in high school - isn't that what she's supposed to be doing?" Gently as I could, I clarified why a young teen with mental health issues is not "supposed" to drink, smoke pot and have sex. I'm not sure if it got through.
Which brings us back to the young man who used the phrase that is the title of this piece. He's had some challenges - that are greatly outweighed by his strengths. He's smart, does quite well in school and has great parental support. He understands that getting high, drunk and having sex are, in his words "stupid" things for someone of his station. But these are things that most all adults have done. The National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism reports that almost 87% of adults have used alcohol. A Gallup poll reports that 38% of Americans have used marijuana. And as only 4% of Americans die as virgins, most all of us, sooner or later, have been sexually active. So virtually all of us engage in these activities, some of us have engaged in many of them.
So, when are we old enough to begin to do stupid things? I don't know. It's obviously dependent on many variables. And I'm not saying that responsible use of psychoactive substances or responsible sexual behavior is bad or good. Sexual activity is a developmentally (not to mention anthropologically and biologically) normal behavior. The use of alcohol (and in some cultures other psychoactive substances) is a part of many religious and social norms. What I do know is that mixing these emotionally demanding behaviors (that statistically, most all of us do or have done) is a bad mix with a brain that's underdeveloped. It's worse for a kid who's experiencing mental health issues. I'm also pretty sure that the kid who questioned when he would be "old enough to do stupid things" has a good shot at success. After all, if he's smart enough to ask the question, he's already showing some wisdom.
I've been seeing this really nice, smart kid from a really good family - his story is pretty irrelevant except for one thing he said recently. We were discussing that as he has been getting older (late teens) his social life has gone the way that is so common. He's smoked marijuana once or twice but hasn't really used alcohol and while he's still a virgin, he's been romantically involved and has engaged in what we might once have referred to as "heavy petting." I'm sure he's interested in more when he has the opportunity. We were discussing his life and some of the stress he's been under and I suggested that until he was stable for a bit longer, that he remain cautious about using substances and becoming sexually active. I quickly qualified to him that I wasn't endorsing or condemning these activities, rather I was acknowledging the realities of our society today.
According to the US National Library of Medicine National Institute of Health, as of March 2014, fully 34% of our youth under the age of 16 reported use of alcohol and marijuana. 21% of high school seniors are current users of marijuana according to the National Institute of Drug Addiction. As we know from even a cursory review of the news, the brain doesn't really stop developing until somewhere in the early 20's. So 34% of our kids are using psychoactive addictive substances when their brains are no more than 75% mature. Not surprisingly, the study concludes that kids who have these habits are those with the higher rates of substance abuse problems. It didn't say, but I'm supposing that the numbers of kids with mental health issues in this population is also high. The CDC reports that over 12% of kids over the age of 12 have used either illegal drugs or have used pharmaceuticals for recreation in the past month. Of high schoolers, CDC reports that 47% have had sexual intercourse, 34% having had intercourse in the last 3 months and of that number, almost 15% didn't use a condom. 15% of high schoolers have had sex with 4 or more partners. These are sobering numbers.
I recently spoke with a mom (dad's not in the picture) about some very troubling behaviors her teen daughter was engaged in - serious depression coupled with serious drug and alcohol use and casual sexual activity. I flatly expressed my concern to mom that her child's emotional stability seemed quite inconsistent with the ability to manage alcohol drug use and sexual activity. Mom's response surprised me, to say the least. She said "She's in high school - isn't that what she's supposed to be doing?" Gently as I could, I clarified why a young teen with mental health issues is not "supposed" to drink, smoke pot and have sex. I'm not sure if it got through.
Which brings us back to the young man who used the phrase that is the title of this piece. He's had some challenges - that are greatly outweighed by his strengths. He's smart, does quite well in school and has great parental support. He understands that getting high, drunk and having sex are, in his words "stupid" things for someone of his station. But these are things that most all adults have done. The National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism reports that almost 87% of adults have used alcohol. A Gallup poll reports that 38% of Americans have used marijuana. And as only 4% of Americans die as virgins, most all of us, sooner or later, have been sexually active. So virtually all of us engage in these activities, some of us have engaged in many of them.
So, when are we old enough to begin to do stupid things? I don't know. It's obviously dependent on many variables. And I'm not saying that responsible use of psychoactive substances or responsible sexual behavior is bad or good. Sexual activity is a developmentally (not to mention anthropologically and biologically) normal behavior. The use of alcohol (and in some cultures other psychoactive substances) is a part of many religious and social norms. What I do know is that mixing these emotionally demanding behaviors (that statistically, most all of us do or have done) is a bad mix with a brain that's underdeveloped. It's worse for a kid who's experiencing mental health issues. I'm also pretty sure that the kid who questioned when he would be "old enough to do stupid things" has a good shot at success. After all, if he's smart enough to ask the question, he's already showing some wisdom.
Thursday, April 9, 2015
Children As Puzzles
We are all fascinated by puzzles of some kind or another. Our professions are samples of different kinds of puzzles. The brain surgeon has to figure out the puzzle of the next surgery, the warehouse worker has to figure out the puzzle of how to order the stock in the warehouse so it can be tracked and pulled when needed. Kids thrive on puzzles. My almost eight year old grandson is fascinated by jigsaw puzzles and Sudoku. Since the days of "Pong" video games have gone through multiple generations of creativity engaging kids and adults into solving the problems in hi-definition. Learning to read - to decode the meaning of letters and their combinations that make words, stories and communication is its own kind of puzzle.
I've been thinking about problems solving in the midst of my training with Ross Greene in his "Collaborative Pro-Active Solutions" model outlined in his The Explosive Child and Lost at School books that have taken root around the world. These books teach that to understand children's behaviors is best done in collaboration with them in defining the problems and then coming up with solutions to the challenges they can bring.
Greene's model of working with kids is one that I have found unique in a number of ways. The most important thing is that it demands that we listen to kids in an extended way, a way that only ends when there is surety that the problem being discussed has been fully addressed by the child. It's not a simple task, but one that is eminently do-able, as its not complex either. It mostly involves listening and reflecting back to the child their statements (think "active listening") until the child convincingly can state that they have really addressed their opinion about the difficulty at hand. Most of the skill is in having patience to let the child concentrate and express their thoughts.
Another unique aspect of the model: it does not include our theories on "why" kids behave the way they do (See "The End of Why Questions" post of 3/2/15) and the lack of theories - even when they are obvious, reasonable and maybe even correct, does something very important: they keep the child engaged in the process of discussing the problem. When we tell kids our erudite conclusions, we run the high risk of excluding them from the process of the discussion. We have, essentially, closed the discussion if the child states anything that is in opposition to our theory. Shutting kids down is obviously a poor way of communicating with them - not a great strategy to solving the puzzle of the child's problems. After all, who better than the child can express their experience?
It seems an obvious position, but one that many clinicians (myself more frequently than I like to admit) often forget. In the almost 9 months I've been using Greene's methodology I've learned a lot as I've left my theories behind. I've learned that kids with autism like to be heard. I've learned that a kid with impaired hearing feels doesn't feel normal when she wears hearing aides (which, by the way, she now regularly wears due to the "problem solving" aspect of the model - something I'm sure to discuss later.) I've learned that a kid with a visual learning disability is much more willing to do his homework if it can be read to her.
Kids and their behavior are not an easy puzzle to figure out, but Greene's model is one that is making it much more successful.
Greene's model of working with kids is one that I have found unique in a number of ways. The most important thing is that it demands that we listen to kids in an extended way, a way that only ends when there is surety that the problem being discussed has been fully addressed by the child. It's not a simple task, but one that is eminently do-able, as its not complex either. It mostly involves listening and reflecting back to the child their statements (think "active listening") until the child convincingly can state that they have really addressed their opinion about the difficulty at hand. Most of the skill is in having patience to let the child concentrate and express their thoughts.
Another unique aspect of the model: it does not include our theories on "why" kids behave the way they do (See "The End of Why Questions" post of 3/2/15) and the lack of theories - even when they are obvious, reasonable and maybe even correct, does something very important: they keep the child engaged in the process of discussing the problem. When we tell kids our erudite conclusions, we run the high risk of excluding them from the process of the discussion. We have, essentially, closed the discussion if the child states anything that is in opposition to our theory. Shutting kids down is obviously a poor way of communicating with them - not a great strategy to solving the puzzle of the child's problems. After all, who better than the child can express their experience?
It seems an obvious position, but one that many clinicians (myself more frequently than I like to admit) often forget. In the almost 9 months I've been using Greene's methodology I've learned a lot as I've left my theories behind. I've learned that kids with autism like to be heard. I've learned that a kid with impaired hearing feels doesn't feel normal when she wears hearing aides (which, by the way, she now regularly wears due to the "problem solving" aspect of the model - something I'm sure to discuss later.) I've learned that a kid with a visual learning disability is much more willing to do his homework if it can be read to her.
Kids and their behavior are not an easy puzzle to figure out, but Greene's model is one that is making it much more successful.
Thursday, March 26, 2015
Mortality and Kids
A robust literature exists on how children understand mortality, and rightly so. Adults struggle greatly with understanding the meaning of life - the meaning of death. The matter cuts to a critical essence of who we are and our most basic questions of existence. I couldn't help but notice that recently I've seen a couple of kids, one with autism and one without, who've confronted mortality. In this, as with all posts, materiel changes in client descriptions are made for reasons of confidentiality.
Harry is a 12 year old boy, small in stature, quiet, whose sister died in a car accident last month when another car jumped the median. His sister is described as a charismatic, smart and involved sibling and child. She had finished college and had begun working in her chosen field, living with Harry and their parents in the meantime, saving her money for a while before getting her own apartment. Harry's parents are, understandably, devastated. Harry, quiet, struggled with how to articulate his feelings at Dawn's death. I asked him about his religious beliefs and he began to discuss his basic understanding about the afterlife, consistent with his religious upbringing. It quickly became clear that his religious education had been thorough, but that this was one of those topics that called for a deeper review of the family's religious doctrine. He wondered whether God was punishing Dawn, was this some Divine retribution for her behavior - though he admitted she was a great sister whom everyone loved. Maybe, he wondered, he and his family were being punished for something - what, he didn't know. Maybe there is no God at all? How do we find meaning in this tragic and senseless loss of life? These are questions that are normal, human and very difficult to answer. Harry's parents, tearfully, are rallying with him to find meaning in something that admittedly does not easily make sense. As we all know, the lessons Harry is learning are those that we all learn one day or another. Painful, but a normal part of human development.
Susie is a 10 year old girl who came to see me due to tantrums that began about a month ago, seemingly out of the blue. She has High Functioning Autism (Asperger's) and has until now been a lovely young lady, her "little professor" presentation not withstanding. It was mentioned in passing that her mom underwent a fairly routine surgery last fall that had unexpected consequences and ended up with complications that took a couple of months to resolve. It was serious, but she was never in danger of death per her physician. Susie was told that all was OK and had no follow up questions about her mom's status. They went around their business, her mother recovered fully and all was well. Until the tantrums began.
As Susie, her dad and mom and I spoke, I learned that her mom's recovery hadn't really finished until about a month before the tantrums began. I asked Susie whether she thought her mom was near death. Not only did she say yes, but she feared that throughout mom's recovery (at home) that mom might at any second, die, inaccurately extrapolating that the tenderness mom had at her surgical site when she came home was permanent, an everlasting vulnerability through which her mom could die. She also stated that she feared she could have the same need for the same surgery her mom needed and that feared dying from it. Her parents' eyes grew wide.
The good news for Susie is that she's smart. We immediately began the education process, having learned that her silence upon being told that her mom's surgery was not as simple as hoped, did not mean she fully understood her mother's prognosis. Her parents understood that they would need to be on guard as to any connection between Susie's behavior and other issues and engaged her multiple times afterwords in discussing what she really understood about lots of things, physical health being high on the list. Two weeks later, Susie came back and the tantrums had stopped. Cold.
Mortality is very hard for us to understand.
Wednesday, March 4, 2015
Panic Attacks and Self Monitoring
As with all posts that describe individual clients, materiel changes in descriptions are made to insure client confidentiality.
Kevin is a pleasant 16 year old junior in high school. He began seeing me due to depression and anxiety a bit more than six months ago and has generally done well, not needing medications for either, though I admit it was close there for a while. He's insightful, thoughtful and a very enjoyable kid to work with. He's struggled a bit with some panic attacks that have been (understandably) frightening. He's smart, but the depression and anxiety distracted his ability to keep the good grades he'd been used to last fall - he's not on the autistic spectrum. He needed to pull his academics up, anticipating the coming focus on college applications and the importance of junior year grades in that process. Pressure, but the kind that most kids tolerate. Since the beginning of the year with a new semester, he has done very well with his academics.
He came in and discussed another panic attack after a 4 month respite from them. So we discussed what was going on around the time of the panic attack that might have triggered it. He was quite clear and didn't hesitate - he had been having a bad day anyway, having not done well on a paper he had worked on and invested a lot of time in. His friends and parents noticed he was a bit edgy but he couldn't really put his finger on the problem. Then he was asked to go to the store by his mom to purchase an item for a recipe she was working on and needed right away. It wasn't there. She needed it. He panicked. Shortness of breath, pounding chest, fears of death. Another panic attack.
He managed this one pretty well. He called his mom who was understanding and quickly helped him see that the priority was his emotional stability much more than the recipe she was making. She encouraged him to just come home, reassuring him that the recipe was not that important. With that, he was able to calm down more quickly then he has in the past. He came home (while his mom went to another store, understanding, to her credit, that he was more overloaded than she had anticipated), and was soon fine, but perplexed about having had another panic attack after having been doing so well.
So Kevin and I began to talk about how self monitoring might be a useful tool in helping him see when and where he's vulnerable to panic attacks. We reviewed past panic attacks and saw a couple of themes - when he feels pressure to meet the needs of others and when he's unhappy with himself.
He rightly asked: now that I know what the triggers might be, what do I do? Which led us to a discussion of self monitoring.
Self monitoring is one of those things that's easy to discuss and easier to advise, but not near as easy to do. Despite that, Kevin has some important insights: He knew he wasn't feeling good about his academic work either time he's had the panic attacks. Last week it was a paper. Then really tried to help his mom - he feared disappointing her when she needed him. The panic attack of 4 months ago had similar themes - his friends were desperate for him to join in an activity when he had schoolwork he needed to do in his weakest subject at a time his grades were slumping. Again the themes of not feeling good about his academic performance connected to the pressure to please others.
Kevin's a good kid. I can't say that he'll never have another panic attack, but he's aware, wanting to learn and seeing that there are times he's vulnerable to emotional distress. I think that's a great start.
Kevin is a pleasant 16 year old junior in high school. He began seeing me due to depression and anxiety a bit more than six months ago and has generally done well, not needing medications for either, though I admit it was close there for a while. He's insightful, thoughtful and a very enjoyable kid to work with. He's struggled a bit with some panic attacks that have been (understandably) frightening. He's smart, but the depression and anxiety distracted his ability to keep the good grades he'd been used to last fall - he's not on the autistic spectrum. He needed to pull his academics up, anticipating the coming focus on college applications and the importance of junior year grades in that process. Pressure, but the kind that most kids tolerate. Since the beginning of the year with a new semester, he has done very well with his academics.
He came in and discussed another panic attack after a 4 month respite from them. So we discussed what was going on around the time of the panic attack that might have triggered it. He was quite clear and didn't hesitate - he had been having a bad day anyway, having not done well on a paper he had worked on and invested a lot of time in. His friends and parents noticed he was a bit edgy but he couldn't really put his finger on the problem. Then he was asked to go to the store by his mom to purchase an item for a recipe she was working on and needed right away. It wasn't there. She needed it. He panicked. Shortness of breath, pounding chest, fears of death. Another panic attack.
He managed this one pretty well. He called his mom who was understanding and quickly helped him see that the priority was his emotional stability much more than the recipe she was making. She encouraged him to just come home, reassuring him that the recipe was not that important. With that, he was able to calm down more quickly then he has in the past. He came home (while his mom went to another store, understanding, to her credit, that he was more overloaded than she had anticipated), and was soon fine, but perplexed about having had another panic attack after having been doing so well.
So Kevin and I began to talk about how self monitoring might be a useful tool in helping him see when and where he's vulnerable to panic attacks. We reviewed past panic attacks and saw a couple of themes - when he feels pressure to meet the needs of others and when he's unhappy with himself.
He rightly asked: now that I know what the triggers might be, what do I do? Which led us to a discussion of self monitoring.
Self monitoring is one of those things that's easy to discuss and easier to advise, but not near as easy to do. Despite that, Kevin has some important insights: He knew he wasn't feeling good about his academic work either time he's had the panic attacks. Last week it was a paper. Then really tried to help his mom - he feared disappointing her when she needed him. The panic attack of 4 months ago had similar themes - his friends were desperate for him to join in an activity when he had schoolwork he needed to do in his weakest subject at a time his grades were slumping. Again the themes of not feeling good about his academic performance connected to the pressure to please others.
Kevin's a good kid. I can't say that he'll never have another panic attack, but he's aware, wanting to learn and seeing that there are times he's vulnerable to emotional distress. I think that's a great start.
Monday, March 2, 2015
The End of "Why" Questions
There is a question that I've long struggled with, despite its
standard use in most of our lexicons, therapist and parent alike. It is arguably
our most frequently used question: "why." "Why did you
(fill in the blank)." This is a standard parenting and therapeutic question.
It so frequently comes up with kids, particularly those with ADHD in
response to their "impulsivity." (See my post of 7/17/13 on
"The Missing 'I' In ADHD").
Asking "why" to a kid with ADHD is almost always silly
question, albeit understandable. Impulsivity means action without
thought. If I was thinking, I wouldn't have bleached the dog's
fur. It’s the Dennis the Menace response that lands him sitting in the
corner – to no long term avail. We ask
"why" because we're programmed from infancy to do so. If we
understand why, we understand a lot. But in the arena of human behavior,
"why" often leads us down a dead end. We've all been there - we
ask "why" and receive no real satisfaction with the answer. We
are quite satisfied, however, with OUR answer of "why" which, as Ross
Greene points out, is usually a theory, often creative, sometimes accurate, but
used often as a figurative club to beat sense into the child. Now I don't
know about you, but I struggle enough with regular questions. When I'm being
emotionally clubbed, I have a much tougher time. When kids are being
emotionally clubbed with our theories, they shut down.
Indeed, the "why" question has been choice in my quiver of questions until recently. I'm using it less and less,
and I may be even approaching the end of "why" questions altogether.
The corner I've turned with "why" questions has come under the
tutelage of Greene who wrote The
Explosive Child and Lost
at School. I'm taking a certification program with him in the model
outlined in these books. "Collaborative Proactive Solutions"
(initially developed under the name of "Collaborative Problem
Solving" until Greene's rights to his own intellectual property was
challenged in court. Another topic for another day.)
In the CPS model Greene asserts that
"why" questions so often lead to a dead end. "Why did you hit
your brother?" is likely to be responded to with a "He's a jerk"
(often said much less graciously) or "He started it" or "He said
I'm a jerk" and the like. How does a parent or a therapist follow up
to such a response? Do we believe that knowing "why" will
inhibit the problem from happening in the future? That thinking is rooted
in the Freudian theory of finding the "kernel" of the problem that,
when explored, extricates the problem like a dandelion pulled from the ground extricating
the entire root system. The problem with dandelion pulling is that it
invariably leaves a fragment of the root in the ground that regenerates.
Like the regenerated dandelion, the answer to “why” does not uproot the behavior
which will invariably rear its ugly head again. Knowing "why"
does not give us the solution - the behavioral change - we want.
We ask "why" I believe, due to
our own inquisitiveness and desire, our need to figure things out and understand
how things work. Why does the apple fall from the tree? Gravity.
Why did my tennis serve not make it over the net? Simple, if I'm able to
learn the mechanics of how to serve a tennis ball. Why did I leave dirty
dishes in the sink? That's actually a complicated question with many
variables and influences. And that's just the dishes! When
exploring the cause of human behavior, it's quite difficult to find a
satisfying answer to "why" mostly because the answer to
"why" doesn't lead to behavioral change. Maybe I didn't do the
dishes because I was tired. Maybe I didn't do the dishes because I'm
angry at my wife for what(ever) happened yesterday and not doing them is my way
to get back at her. Maybe I didn't do the dishes because it's an
expression of my sublimated rage for my mother's ignoring my emotional needs
when I was three. Yes, theories can be very creative.
Greene famously talks about a child who he
treated who was quite the behavioral challenge and had gone through many
therapists, more interventions, all to no avail. The common narrative
about the child had to do with the "theory" (code for
"why") of the tragic death of his father when he was a toddler.
It was taken as faith that if he could fully explore his grief, his
behavior would be wholly uprooted and all would be well. When Greene
asked the child about his father's death, the kid looked at him quizzically and
responded that there were no real memories of his dad. The child was two
years old when he died. The theory connecting the behavior to the loss of
the mother was not applicable. This is not to say that dads are
unimportant – or that the child might not benefit from some “dad” based
discussion, but we have to include what kids' experience is in solving the
problem.
What's a therapist (or parent) to do?
That, says Greene, involves engaging the child in a very specific
definition of what the problem actually is and then collaborating with the
child to find a solution. Which is a discussion for a different post
(stay tuned). In the meantime, I encourage you to consider: is the payoff
for the "why" questions getting you where you want with your kids?
Friday, February 20, 2015
Strong Parents
It's been a week where I've seen a number of strong parents, some of whom I've known for years, some who I've just met. Just thought I'd share some vignettes. As always, materiel changes to identifying data have been made to protect confidentiality.
I've known one mom on and off for a while. She has a 9 year old boy on the spectrum who has a lot of strengths, but the oft found challenges of rigidity, difficulty transitioning and difficulty when the plan he anticipates changes. He struggles with anxiety for which he receives medications that help some. His younger sister, 8, is NT (neuro-typical) and while they've never discussed "autism" or "Asperger's" or "spectrum" outright, they have broadly discussed "differences" that people have. Mom, to her great credit, has been "seeding" the family environment with kid friendly books about developmental differences, working to normalize her son's experience for him as well as for his sister. She's also done a great job with "narrative" stories she's found. For example, a story about the kid who was unable to comfortably speak with strangers (no coincidence this is one of her son's challenges.) The story tells of a child who struggles with this, and who gradually learns that his anxiety about speaking to strangers is able to be surmounted. Her son's begun, like the boy in the story, to speak more comfortably to strangers. Mom's job is flexible. She has the time to investigate, research and advocate for her son and has done so admirably.
Another couple came to me recently with their son who's on the spectrum and also has borderline cognitive functioning. They were well aware of the impact and limitations of both diagnoses. They have been most diligent in following up with recommendations, particularly after their son said - let's call them unwise things - at school when he became angry. They jumped way out ahead of the curve understanding that such statements can be misinterpreted, particularly in the "small world" environment in which we now live. They understand that threatening talk of any kind has been seen as preceding horrific behaviors and though there are no indications of this child's potential for violence, they are being most proactive in searching for solutions. They quickly follow up on recommendations and have a very good comprehension of their child's needs.
One single mom I've known for years always impresses me. She has a full time job that isn't particularly challenging or fulfilling, but allows her the flexibility to be there for her son with autism. She plans ahead - not in an anxious way (professionals who work with challenged populations are quite familiar with the questions about "will he/she be able to get married, have children, live independently when the child's ages is still in single digits. I understand the anxiety the absorption of the implications of the diagnoses has....) She plans, for example, for spend the night company. "What kinds of things do you think your friend might like to know when spending the night in a new home?" Then she suggests that her son give a house tour to the guest. She suggests her son inquire of the guest about food preferences. Suggestions about how to be a host and allow the guest to pick out the game to be played on the x-box among many other suggestions. All of this led to, no surprise, a very successful sleepover.
These may seem like simple, obvious examples of parent strength, but having seen lots of parents who struggle mightily with the stress of raising kids on and off the spectrum, it's nice to see.
I've known one mom on and off for a while. She has a 9 year old boy on the spectrum who has a lot of strengths, but the oft found challenges of rigidity, difficulty transitioning and difficulty when the plan he anticipates changes. He struggles with anxiety for which he receives medications that help some. His younger sister, 8, is NT (neuro-typical) and while they've never discussed "autism" or "Asperger's" or "spectrum" outright, they have broadly discussed "differences" that people have. Mom, to her great credit, has been "seeding" the family environment with kid friendly books about developmental differences, working to normalize her son's experience for him as well as for his sister. She's also done a great job with "narrative" stories she's found. For example, a story about the kid who was unable to comfortably speak with strangers (no coincidence this is one of her son's challenges.) The story tells of a child who struggles with this, and who gradually learns that his anxiety about speaking to strangers is able to be surmounted. Her son's begun, like the boy in the story, to speak more comfortably to strangers. Mom's job is flexible. She has the time to investigate, research and advocate for her son and has done so admirably.
Another couple came to me recently with their son who's on the spectrum and also has borderline cognitive functioning. They were well aware of the impact and limitations of both diagnoses. They have been most diligent in following up with recommendations, particularly after their son said - let's call them unwise things - at school when he became angry. They jumped way out ahead of the curve understanding that such statements can be misinterpreted, particularly in the "small world" environment in which we now live. They understand that threatening talk of any kind has been seen as preceding horrific behaviors and though there are no indications of this child's potential for violence, they are being most proactive in searching for solutions. They quickly follow up on recommendations and have a very good comprehension of their child's needs.
One single mom I've known for years always impresses me. She has a full time job that isn't particularly challenging or fulfilling, but allows her the flexibility to be there for her son with autism. She plans ahead - not in an anxious way (professionals who work with challenged populations are quite familiar with the questions about "will he/she be able to get married, have children, live independently when the child's ages is still in single digits. I understand the anxiety the absorption of the implications of the diagnoses has....) She plans, for example, for spend the night company. "What kinds of things do you think your friend might like to know when spending the night in a new home?" Then she suggests that her son give a house tour to the guest. She suggests her son inquire of the guest about food preferences. Suggestions about how to be a host and allow the guest to pick out the game to be played on the x-box among many other suggestions. All of this led to, no surprise, a very successful sleepover.
These may seem like simple, obvious examples of parent strength, but having seen lots of parents who struggle mightily with the stress of raising kids on and off the spectrum, it's nice to see.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)