Monday, May 16, 2016

High School Social Rule Confusion for High Schoolers With High Functioning Autism

As with all posts, materiel changes have been made to protect confidentiality.

Jim is a pretty typical high school junior.  He's quite smart, particularly in science and math and is quite socially awkward, not in small part due to his longstanding diagnosis of Asperger's (now categorized as "high functioning autism" (HFA) but let's not get too stuck on labels here.)

Though Jim's never dated, he has a couple of geeky friends who are boys with whom he gets together to play video games and discuss their books replete with complex development of other worldly characters.  Fantasy and science fiction have an almost Biblical status for Jim and his friends, to the point that they sometimes forego their school work while engaging in reading or playing video games consistent with their passions.

So Jim was caught off guard recently when one of the girls in school inserted herself into the mix of Jim and his friends.  She continued what adolescents have been doing with one another since the dawn of, well, since the dawn of adolescent life; she began to "split" Jim and his friends for no clear reason.  (I theorize that the girl may have been exhibiting her own brand of flirting with either Jim or his friends, but didn't have the sophistication to do it kindly.)

She began by engaging Jim in a discussion about his close friend.  Jim, naively fell into the trap of saying something negative about his closest friend that the girl immediately brought to his friend's attention.  Thus the split; Jim and his good friend were now fighting, the girl is able to create a connection with the friend.  A play that's as readable as a sacrifice bunt moving the runner to second base, and often as effective.

What Jim's struggling with his that he was the sacrifice, or to put it in group dynamic terms: he was "triangulated out" of the group.  By aligning with Jim's friend against Jim, the girl was able to create a close(r) relationship to his friend and create animosity from the friend to Jim.  The friend believes that Jim betrayed him, all this at the hands of the girl.  It's pretty easy to understand, unless you're Jim.

Jim's thinking is fairly concrete, not unusual for someone with HFA.  Jim is forlorn, he misses his friend, and just doesn't understand what happened.  These are emotions with which he's unfamiliar.  They were tight, and now they are not. He was misunderstood, why can't his friend understand?  Why is his friend taking so long to get over the fact that they were played against one another (the girl, apparently in this case, has moved on.)

This kind of social difficulty is quite common for kids on the spectrum.  He's stuck on the betrayal he feels from the girl's distortion of his words.  He's sad at the potential for having lost a friend.  He doesn't know what to do.  And I don't have a simple solution.

Tony Attwood explained the experience of this population well in one of his early books on Asperger's when he said (I believe in the name of one of his clients) that being here on earth feels like being a Martian who's arrived on a strange planet with strange rules.  That is, the rules here are unknown, mysterious, random, and the learning curve to adapt to this civilization is long and complex.  This is the dilemma Jim's going through.  He's pained by not understanding the emotional gamesmanship that are the complexity of adolescents, and feels victimized.  We discussed the "rules" of hurtful communication like this - indeed they are hard to understand, but Jim's smart, I think he'll do OK.  Like the rest of us, he needs time to heal.

Tuesday, April 5, 2016

Random Sentences, Powerful Words

"I feel broken."  "I'm afraid I'll be killed [because I'm a black male]" "My dad didn't teach me how to make friends."

I've heard these three statements recently from three different clients and they've given me pause to think.  Each has been a powerful statement that has stuck in my mind.  Without revealing anything that would violate the speakers' confidentiality, I'd like to comment.

"I feel broken."  This from a young man who grew up in a violent home, his parents physically hurting one another and their children.  His parents throwing hurtful comments at one another and the kids.  This young man is smart, quite smart in fact and his diagnosis of Asperger's is not immediately apparent when first meeting him.  Despite his autism, he's struggling with how to establish healthy adult relationships, fearful that any relationship he enters will replicate the pain he experienced as a child.  His pain is palpable and fills our sessions. His strengths are as evident: intelligence, wit, wisdom.  How will he move past his pain and into his strengths?  I look forward to see the course of our discussions and his move through anxiety will allow for repair of what he experiences as broken.

"I'm afraid I'll be killed [because I'm a black male]."  A smart and athletic pre-teen old said this recently in our first meeting.  He's learned of our culture's increased awareness of the violence perpetrated upon black men by the police via the news, what is being said in school and the community.  His fear has turned into anxiety and depression and, as can happen with anxiety and depression, he has sometimes exhibited anger.  Anger, of course, is a touchstone issue for the African American community and AA men in particular.  The stream of anger in response to the black experience is as old as slavery itself, a hurt that is documented in the Bible and continues to plague our society to this day.  The understandable anger of this history, both recent and long past, is the very thing that makes him vulnerable to being "profiled" or identified by the white community as being a danger.  And he knows this.  His parents know this.  His simple plea "I'm afraid I'll be killed" sticks in my mind as the plea of countless generations of people burdened by hate.  Its the historic cry of enslaved people of color, of women enslaved in sexual slavery, of children conscripted in war to kill their neighbors and family, of citizens who walk the street in almost any country fearing a suicide bomber.  How can this beautiful child move into a society where he will be seen in the same light of God as whomever is viewing him?

"My mom didn't teach me how to make friends."  I heard this recently and was amazed at the desperation of the comment.  This was a young woman just out of high school who was floundering, drinking heavily and emotionally struggling and searching.  She's smart, but terribly confused about her burden.  Her mother's contributions to her current status is marginal.  Her hope to successfully blame her mother will fail.  Her first and foremost problem is her episodic but excessive drinking that renders her severely depressed with all of the anticipated results severe depression brings.  Anything else to address has to happen after she stops using alcohol.  I rarely pity someone, but when I heard this desperate statement, a cry of hopelessness, I pitied her.
These statements have impacted me and led to my becoming more introspective, considering the power of the words I say and the words my clients say when considering their existence.  Words are powerful.  I encourage the reader to consider theirs deeply.

Monday, March 7, 2016

Family Dynamics and Sibling Order Counts - Even In Our 90's

A friend of mine told me of an interesting exchange between two elderly siblings that, I think, sheds a very interesting light on the power of sibling relationships and, by extension, the power of family dynamics.

The elder sibling, let's call him Tom, is close to his 95th birthday and is approaching that milestone in relatively good health.  That be said, he is experiencing increasing short term memory loss that results in an in between status.  There are some things he's able to discuss quite cogently.  Other things are difficult for him due to his memory loss.  His presentation is also marked by his significant hearing loss.  All in all, not atypical for a 95 year old guy.

His brother Sam is 91.  Sam's career was similar to his older brother's, they've not lived in the same city since the late 50's and were not particularly close as their lives led them through the roller coaster of raising children, career, retirement and after decades of marriage, the loss of their respective wives.  In retirement they began to speak a bit more frequently and even vacationed with one another a few times.  It was a pretty traditional sibling relationship.

Sam was recently was diagnosed with cancer.  Upon receiving the diagnosis his doctor advised that at 91 he might opt for palliative care.  Doing so would allow Sam time to make sure his affairs were in order and prepare for what's to come in an orderly fashion.  Sam, a product of the era that listened to doctors' advice seriously, considered the recommendation while his children (wisely, I think) immediately embarked upon a search for a second opinion.  The second doctor ultimately strongly encouraged treating the cancer and Sam is now in treatment.

But before that second opinion happened, Sam spoke with his almost 95 year old brother, Tom who didn't hesitate in his recommendation that the cancer be treated.  Sam's daughter remarked at how quickly Sam listened to Tom's rationale which was a common sensical "Why not?  What have you got to lose?" Immediately after hanging up the phone, before the second opinion with another doctor, Sam announced to his kids that he would pursue treatment.  Tom said so, and that was it.

Now Tom's opinion, if I might say, was not particularly a rocket science conclusion.  Sam's 91, so what indeed does he have to lose?  More importantly, what was it about his older brother's comment that swung his opinion?    His daughter who related the story to me was clear - Sam's decision to pursue treatment was made on his older brother's recommendation and guidance.  The imploring of his 4 kids who were united in their desire for Sam to get treatment did not sway him.

It strikes me how deeply our family relationships effect us, often in ways we might not even know.  Our roles as parents, our roles as children and yes, our roles as siblings.  The imprinting we receive as a result of our families of origin is as deep as it is subtle.  Even at the age of 91, putting medical recommendations and the pleading of children aside, it was the simple comment of an older brother that swayed Sam.  Such is the power of a family system, the power of how familial roles can impact our views and decisions

Wednesday, March 2, 2016

Eyes Wide Open

As with all posts in this blog, materiel changes are made to protect the identity of clients.

Jimmy's been a tough kid to work with.  When addressed he often buries his head in mom's lap or into the cushions of the couch.  His dad isn't in the picture, but mom's boyfriend, in the home for 6 years, has been a warm and beneficial presence in Jimmy's life.  He's 10 and is a classically ADHD oppositional kid at home and school.  He's bright, and as I often tell parents, "smart + ADHD = (often) a tougher kid."

He recently was suspended.  Again.  We've been using The "Collaborative and Proactive Solutions" model I've been discussing so frequently in these posts.  See elsewhere for more background on that.  The CPS model works pretty well with him, but admittedly there have been limits - mom's work doesn't allow for much flexibility, so we've not been able to meet as frequently as needed.

None the less, I struck forth with my "what's up" questioning about the difficulty he had in school upon receiving a routine homework assignment.  He was hard to reach, but I persisted and was patient, as is often required in the "drilling" process of the "empathy step" where we ask the child about the problem, trying to learn as much as possible about his experience as he tried to tunnel into the couch.

Slowly, a bit painfully, Jimmy was able to explain the latest outburst that led to this suspension.  He mentioned that "it wasn't written on the board."  Mom and I looked at one another, both of us not understanding the statement.  I asked further and he related that whenever there's to be homework in the class it's written on the board when he walks in the room so he's prepared to write it down when cued at the end of class.  That day the teacher hadn't written it down prior to the kids entering the room, so he didn't anticipate homework that day.

Mom's eyes opened wide in acknowledgement of Jimmy's description of the essence of the problem at the same time that I clarified with him that this indeed was the issue that led to his explosion. Moving to the "problem solving" stage of the process was a fairly easy, with the caveat that mom couldn't really "collaborate" on behalf of the school, but she was optimistic that she'd be able to communicate to the teacher and staff what the issue was and how they might "collaborate" with Jimmy to avoid such problems in the future.

I've seen parents' eyes open wide like this in the past when using the CPS method.  It's always a bit exciting when they see into their child's experience.  I'll be interested in hearing how Jimmy's homework issues in that class have been addressed when we next meet.  

Monday, February 8, 2016

Explosive Kids, Parents and Timing

As with all posts, any description of people I see in therapy is materially changed for reasons of confidentiality

One of my favorite jokes is when I ask a person to ask me ..."what's the key to good comedy?"j  Before they finish the sentence, I interrupt them with the answer "timing."  It's a great joke and I was reminded of it recently.

It started as a mess but resulted in a great step forward with a couple I've worked with for many years.  Theirs is a complicated history, well beyond the scope of this posting.  One problem is that they have a tendency to fight.  Hard.  Ugly.  In front of the kids. You can use your imagination as to how hurtful it becomes.  It's a toxic habit they've just not been able to break despite all they know and despite all of my strategies and interventions.

Coming to see me recently they had another fight, this one in the car.  They walked in the door, sat down calmly and noted that often the only time they have to communicate with one another (given the demands of work and kids) is when they're coming to or leaving my office. (The sardonic humorist in me speculated that the answer might be to discontinue coming to see me to reduce the fighting.) As they discussed it he said, gently, that he just wasn't prepared to continue the discussion at that moment.  The heat was still too high and he was still too hurt by the vitriol she had spewed (see above re: ugly and hard - you can use your imagination.)  She agreed that it wasn't the time.  And that was that.  The anger dissipated.  They still had things to work on, but now just wasn't the time.  For this couple it was a major step forward.  Fighting when angry is so often just destructive, whether in marriage or between parent and child.

Which got me to thinking about "proactive" intervention, discussed at length in Ross Greene's "Collaborative and Proactive Solutions" model outlined in his book The Explosive Child.  I'm thinking about his model a lot (if you've read any of the recent posts) in my work with kids, and, it works out, with adults.

Being proactive means that the intervention being used is one that is done at a calm time, but that is targeted to a known problem that is certain to recur.  "Emotional Focused Couples Therapy" recommends the same technique when working with couples that Greene recommends in CPS.  We know what problems are coming down the road.  Thus we need to focus on them before they reach us and not when they are upon us.  It's a common sense approach, but one that requires planning.  In the ADHD world we live in where "distractability" is the norm, being proactive is difficult to accomplish.  I'd also pose that "reactivity" isn't such a great approach.  Think for a moment - how well is being reactive working as compare to those times that you take the time to proactively discuss a problem and come up with a solution.  Being proactive invites collaboration - there's a lot less emotional heat, a lot less ego in the discussion, less pride, all of which allows for a much better solution.

Whether in marriage, with kids, at work, doesn't being proactive make more sense?  It just requires doing something a bit different.  We're all used to doing things differently, we know change is a constant in life.  This is one thing that when changed, changes a lot.

Tuesday, January 12, 2016

Drilling and The Explosive Child

"Drilling" is how, in Collaborative and Proactive Solutions (from Ross Greene's The Explosive Child), we learn more about children's thoughts and feelings regarding problems posed to them.  Drilling for information is not, as Greene aptly states, "grilling."  Children are not to be interrogated.  They are to be questioned in a way that aligns us with them - which is a different conceptualization than the traditional hierarchic structure most of us are used to - the family system having its "executive branch" of the parents and the children being "subordinate" to them.  And while I'm not opposed to this model - indeed I see great benefit to it - with certain kids there's a limit to what this model can achieve.  Thus, collaboration.

Paula is an almost 10 year old girl in a family that I've been working with for a while.  There have been many challenges that are not pertinent for this discussion (the reader will note that all clinical examples are materially changed for reasons of confidentiality) but the issue at hand for Paula is homework.

Admittedly, she has some challenges in her math skills - particularly when working with dad, for reasons that became clear as we drilled, meaning essentially that we pursued a line of thought re: the problem at hand.  We began with the broad ("clumped" in Greene's language) problem of "agreeing on when to begin homework."  When asked which homework was the most likely to have a hard time agreeing about, she admitted it was math.  Now math is a pretty broad subject, it has lots of pieces.  We explored this and she was able to clarify that her toughest area was when she had to address:
1. new math concepts that had been recently introduced in class
2. some fraction concepts
3. understanding which math operation was indicated by simple word problems.

Well, that's a lot less "clumped" isn't it?

It might be tempting to wrap it up there.  But until she says that we've fully understood the problem, we continue to drill.  How does dad's presence effect her difficulty in doing homework?  Paula's response?  She doesn't like simply to be "told what to do" with the homework by dad.  Well, that's interesting isn't it?  How many of us would assume that telling the child what do is helping them with their homework?  Not so much for Paula.

Were we done?  We used the simple "review and ask" drilling suggestion.  We reviewed that she had difficulty:
1. with new math concepts
2. with some fraction concepts
3. understanding which math operation was indicated by simple word problems
4. being simply told what to do when stuck doing math

Anything else difficult doing the math homework?  She fidgeted in her seat and paused.  Her older sister Natalie told her she's "dumb" because she doesn't do math as well as Natalie.  She teared, she was sad.  It was easy to see how difficult this was for her.  When asked what else might be going on, Paula was clear, we had it all.  This was it, these were the problems she experienced with math.

So we now end up with 5 problems - the last being the teasing from Natlalie - as interfering with her ability to do her math homework.

In CPS we want to de-clump the problems.  We do so by asking, drilling, for more information.  We ultimately learned with Paula there are 5 problems, not one.  So when it comes to problem solving, we now have 5 things to collaborate about.  Is it do-able?  Yes.  More complicated? Yes.  Does Paula deserve the time and focus on these problems?  Of course - she's their child!

One of the criticisms I've heard about CPS is that it "takes too long."  That may be. But I think Paula's worth taking the time to collaborate on each and every problem she has with math so that she can
1. get the math
2. learn that she can solve problems with her parents' help and guidance
3. learn that Natalie may not be right.

It may take more time, but by devoting the time more prescriptively, more accurately, we may accomplish a lot, and make Paula's future math and math homework experience a lot easier.


I'd day those are worthwhile goals.


Thursday, December 10, 2015

The Explosive Child: Case Example and Upcoming Training

Moshe will be offering a parent training group on The Explosive Child by Ross Greene Ph.D.  The 4 week group will teach parents the fundamentals of Collaborative and Proactive Solutions, the methodology Greene developed.  It begins Monday January 25th, 2016 and continue for 4 consecutive evenings from 6:15-7:45 at the offices of ASCEND Pediatric Neurology.  The fee is $300 per individual or $500 for a couple.  Please contact Moshe for more information.  

If you know me, or have read these blogs, you know that I've become quite a fan of CPS.  Here's a recent example (as in all postings, materiel changes have been made in order to protect confidentiality):

Denise is a 7 year old who has no diagnosis of any kind that is discernible at this time, with the exception of a strong oppositional streak.  She refuses to do anything educationally except participate in selected group activities she enjoys through the home schooling network in which her mom has her enrolled.  She's not enrolled in any certified educational school program - parents had begun home schooling and she ratcheted down the expectations to include only social activites.  I educated parents in CPS and when I first met her she was openly hostile to me, even as I took a very "collaborative" position, assuring her that the only thing I was interested in was her input to solve problems that the family might be having.  I followed the CPS recipe carefully, withholding my impulses to put this young lady in her place (ODD kids are able to bring forth those urges in adults.)  I later admitted to parents that this kid actually scared me - she really did.  I wondered how I'd ever get through to her.  

Long story short - we were able to use the model to successfully collaborate on toy clean up and bedtime routines.  And despite her assurance to me that she would NOT attend school, she's begun to do so.  I did tell her we'd be needing to collaborate on a solution about school, adding, for her to consider, that when we did so we would have to address the issue of truancy, as she had not been enrolled in any certified program for over a year.

CPS, a hot knife through the butter of oppositionality.  How's that for a saying?