We don't have a TV in our home. We did, but given work schedules and our viewing preferences, we canceled it and saved the money. Netflix gives me all I need. So I'm generally immune from the advertising that rules the airwaves. Until I travel.
So recently when I was at a conference I tuned it, caught up on World Cup play, which is thankfully commercial free, and then tuned in to a "world premiere" of a show I had seen advertised - at a movie no less. It had all the compelling aspects of shows I like. Action, military, science etc. The cost of watching it was re-entry into the world of commercial expectations. Boy do we have expectations.
In one car commercial, sequences of horribly damaged cars were accompanied by the statement "They lived." Wow. So now, regardless of how horribly I crash, I should have the expectation of living through it. And another commercial, also for a car, I learned that no matter how distracted I am, my car can and should correct for my mistakes. Veer too much from my lane, it informs me. Approach a vehicle in front of me too fast, it brakes for me.
Now I'm not opposed to smart(er) cars, just like I'm not opposed to smart(er) phones or computers. I am concerned that expectations of our own responsibility is being shaped to decrease our sense of self and relationship with the world.
Interestingly, I read an article recently about divorces in later life, after 20+ years of marriage. One of the professionals interviewed opined that the increase in divorce of this population is due to the increased frequency of people's expectations being raised about how much they deserve, how much they "should" get from life. This seems to be a (natural?) expansion of the selling of sex that has accompanied advertising for at 150 years. Google "Pearl Tobacco" if you need proof. I don't think even then that anyone would have actually thought that smoking a Pearl would cause naked women to approach. But the claims seem to have gone so much further now. Horrible auto crashes should be, not could be survived. Irresponsible driving should be intercepted by our machines. We don't need to be responsible any more.
I hope I'm not the only one who has a problem with that line of thinking.
Monday, June 23, 2014
Monday, June 9, 2014
Mom Gets a Sticker or Teaching Johnny to Swim.
So much of the work that I do with kids is centered on parents. A recent case in point is a mom of a precocious 1st grade boy who had been nervous about learning new things like learning how to swim, hesitance to learn to ride a bike, even spending time with other kids his age.
He was a cute kid, precocious, as I said, easily engaged in talk and play. Grades were good, behavior was OK. So.....what about that anxiety?
Well, as family therapists are wont to do, I began to explore the family of origin. Mom admitted that she was raised under a specter of "danger." Everything had a dangerous side to it. Really dangerous. This sense of danger was reinforced by a tragic nonfatal accident that one of her father's nephews had suffered as a young adult. Thus grandpa held his breath whenever this little boy did...well...just about anything. And of course grandpa lived close, transmitting his anxiety in a potent and frequent way to both his daughter and grandson. And of course mom felt great responsibility to not heighten her father's anxiety. So, it follows that mom held her breath - loudly -whenever her little boy attempted to do those things that are normal for little boys to do. He learned, in turn, to hesitate a bit, in deference to his mother's anxiety on behalf of her father. You get the picture. Thus, we have a recipe for a child with anxiety. Kind of.
I recall so clearly that at the end of the first meeting mom anxiously sat forward on her seat and asked, tears forming and beginning to roll down her cheek, if there was "hope" for her beloved son. I wasn't sure what she really meant. Sure there was hope, I responded, curious why she was so concerned. The tears of relief flowed as I used one of my favorite lines: "I'm not going to lose sleep about you or your son this weekend." I did not predict horrible things in the life of her son. (As if we have crystal balls through which we can predict all coming events!)
Mom quickly came to understand the dilemma she created in transferring anxiety "down the generational line" from her father to her to her son. The solution was pretty straightforward, as mom now admits. The first thing mom agreed to do was to check her own anxiety at the door. Family therapy theory discusses pushing the dysfunction "up" the generational ladder. She, not her father was the parent of this boy. She knows kids need to learn how to swim, bike etc. despite her father's trauma with his nephew. But how to reverse the tide? The answer was a simple behavioral intervention - understanding what was "reinforcing" to her son.
She said she'd tried lots of rewards to motivate him to participate in activities about which she had been giving big mixed messages. She signed him up for swim lessons, and he, in perfect form, cried about swimming. He had a bike, but was afraid to learn to ride it. Motivations? Stickers failed. Food (often a dangerous reinforcement, but not universally) was not a first choice as her son was already large for his age. So I asked him - what would HE like to get if he participated in the upcoming swim lessons He drew a blank. It's better if kids of almost any age come up with their own reinforcement when trying to get them to participate in something. This was about developing or increasing a new behavior, not inhibiting a "maladaptive" behavior. But when a child is a bit on the shy side, I'll toss out some of the tried and true options.
So I went fishing - it didn't take long. Stickers were out, TV and video games were appropriately limited by mom, so I was hesitant to go there. Food? Nope. Going to the pool is a great reinforcement for some kids, but not this one, not yet. Extra "play dates" with peers can be a good draw, but this boy has a record of being a bit shy. How about staying up a bit late after participating in the swim lesson? His eyes lit up. Bingo.
Mom was game, and in 2 weeks the report was perfect. He not only had participated in the swim lesson but was now swimming on his own, head in the water and on those days he did so, mom or dad stayed up with him an extra half hour - an easy accommodation during summer break. The reinforcement combined two most powerful reinforcers: staying up late, a sign of maturity, growth and responsibility, and parent attention during that extra half hour. Parents were aware that they needed to begin to wean the "reinforcement" pretty quickly which they had spontaneously begun to do - once he was swimming. We discussed that "reinforcements" are establishing an economic model. Now as my son the economist will tell you, I know diddly about economics. But I know enough to know that parents are the rulers of economics with children. Reinforcements can be established, changed or cancelled, as the situation demanded. These parents understood that there is no need to waste a working reinforcement when a behavioral goal (swimming) is established. Save it for other goals. Mom continues to be aware that the anxiety specter loomed, but was working hard at keeping her goal on the child's needs, not her father's anxiety. That'll be a work in progress that we can address as needed.
Mom's still nervous about her dad's anxiety, but is giving a strong signal to her son of what is of real value. The bike's next. The shyness? Who knows where that will end up? Mom? She got a sticker and her son didn't even want one.
He was a cute kid, precocious, as I said, easily engaged in talk and play. Grades were good, behavior was OK. So.....what about that anxiety?
Well, as family therapists are wont to do, I began to explore the family of origin. Mom admitted that she was raised under a specter of "danger." Everything had a dangerous side to it. Really dangerous. This sense of danger was reinforced by a tragic nonfatal accident that one of her father's nephews had suffered as a young adult. Thus grandpa held his breath whenever this little boy did...well...just about anything. And of course grandpa lived close, transmitting his anxiety in a potent and frequent way to both his daughter and grandson. And of course mom felt great responsibility to not heighten her father's anxiety. So, it follows that mom held her breath - loudly -whenever her little boy attempted to do those things that are normal for little boys to do. He learned, in turn, to hesitate a bit, in deference to his mother's anxiety on behalf of her father. You get the picture. Thus, we have a recipe for a child with anxiety. Kind of.
I recall so clearly that at the end of the first meeting mom anxiously sat forward on her seat and asked, tears forming and beginning to roll down her cheek, if there was "hope" for her beloved son. I wasn't sure what she really meant. Sure there was hope, I responded, curious why she was so concerned. The tears of relief flowed as I used one of my favorite lines: "I'm not going to lose sleep about you or your son this weekend." I did not predict horrible things in the life of her son. (As if we have crystal balls through which we can predict all coming events!)
Mom quickly came to understand the dilemma she created in transferring anxiety "down the generational line" from her father to her to her son. The solution was pretty straightforward, as mom now admits. The first thing mom agreed to do was to check her own anxiety at the door. Family therapy theory discusses pushing the dysfunction "up" the generational ladder. She, not her father was the parent of this boy. She knows kids need to learn how to swim, bike etc. despite her father's trauma with his nephew. But how to reverse the tide? The answer was a simple behavioral intervention - understanding what was "reinforcing" to her son.
She said she'd tried lots of rewards to motivate him to participate in activities about which she had been giving big mixed messages. She signed him up for swim lessons, and he, in perfect form, cried about swimming. He had a bike, but was afraid to learn to ride it. Motivations? Stickers failed. Food (often a dangerous reinforcement, but not universally) was not a first choice as her son was already large for his age. So I asked him - what would HE like to get if he participated in the upcoming swim lessons He drew a blank. It's better if kids of almost any age come up with their own reinforcement when trying to get them to participate in something. This was about developing or increasing a new behavior, not inhibiting a "maladaptive" behavior. But when a child is a bit on the shy side, I'll toss out some of the tried and true options.
So I went fishing - it didn't take long. Stickers were out, TV and video games were appropriately limited by mom, so I was hesitant to go there. Food? Nope. Going to the pool is a great reinforcement for some kids, but not this one, not yet. Extra "play dates" with peers can be a good draw, but this boy has a record of being a bit shy. How about staying up a bit late after participating in the swim lesson? His eyes lit up. Bingo.
Mom was game, and in 2 weeks the report was perfect. He not only had participated in the swim lesson but was now swimming on his own, head in the water and on those days he did so, mom or dad stayed up with him an extra half hour - an easy accommodation during summer break. The reinforcement combined two most powerful reinforcers: staying up late, a sign of maturity, growth and responsibility, and parent attention during that extra half hour. Parents were aware that they needed to begin to wean the "reinforcement" pretty quickly which they had spontaneously begun to do - once he was swimming. We discussed that "reinforcements" are establishing an economic model. Now as my son the economist will tell you, I know diddly about economics. But I know enough to know that parents are the rulers of economics with children. Reinforcements can be established, changed or cancelled, as the situation demanded. These parents understood that there is no need to waste a working reinforcement when a behavioral goal (swimming) is established. Save it for other goals. Mom continues to be aware that the anxiety specter loomed, but was working hard at keeping her goal on the child's needs, not her father's anxiety. That'll be a work in progress that we can address as needed.
Mom's still nervous about her dad's anxiety, but is giving a strong signal to her son of what is of real value. The bike's next. The shyness? Who knows where that will end up? Mom? She got a sticker and her son didn't even want one.
Tuesday, May 27, 2014
Turning Corners in Therapy, Diagnostic, Historic and Dynamic
I'll call him Mike. He's 18, finishing HS and came to see me with a diagnosis of Asperger's disorder (or, per our new DSM, High Functioning Autistic Spectrum Disorder, HFA for short) and never quite fit the bill. Or did he? He was the ever logical thinker. Feelings were always framed in thoughts. He would sometimes get angry and would always justify and rationalize it. He had a utilitarian view of school - if a class appealed to him, he'd participate and do well. If it didn't, he would all but ignore it. Relationships with peers, family were always distant, strained and his participation was based on his logical deduction of its need. Lots of HFA characteristics.
He comes from a normal suburban Atlanta family. Mom was in her second marriage, but the couple had been married for 20 years and seemed to have nothing more than their own brand of normal ups and downs of 20 years of raising kids - Mike, with HFA (and ADHD, of course, so frequently found in kids with any developmental difference) but did OK together. His sibs, older and younger, were all pursuing their individual lives. Finances were OK. No drug or alcohol problems. No "systemic" family issues which us family therapists love to ferret out.
So Mike and I began to meet and talk, the "chief complaint" being his anger, compliance with school etc. When we began to meet 1 1/2 years ago he had been suspended for his arguing, stridently, with a teacher. Over time we met weekly at first, and then as things calmed, less frequently. We discussed his academic prowess - science was really his thing. Science covered everything. Science could account for virtually every aspect of life's challenges and choices. And when science failed, math could be substituted. Yeah, Aspie - ish. It was the "ish" that continued to nag at me.
Also consistent with the diagnoses were the behavioral problems in school as well as his lack of emotional regulation. At one point had thoughts of suicide that landed him in a local psychiatric hospital. Very Aspie. Happens all the time.
We spent time reviewing his relationships with his family. Standard family therapy practice, sometimes including his parents. Lots of time was spent reviewing his relationships with his siblings, parents, communication styles. Suggestions and strategies. And of course, the (dreaded) obsession with video games.
Most of our time was spent strategizing how he could best approach the academics he did not enjoy. He's so smart that I (and his parents) felt this to be a very critical concern. While his logic was great, it seemed to fail re: the importance of passing Spanish, a requirement for his graduation. Aspie. He was very critical of certain teachers, scoffed at the uselessness of certain assignments. All the classic things these guys can get hung up on. His high level of intelligence, sometimes well engaged, sometimes not made it all the more frustrating to his parents (yes, and to me.)
We slogged through some of the computer based classes he had to take to make up incomplete work - and then, surprisingly,wonderfully, things began to turn around. His work was getting done, his attitude better (relatively, of course.) What happened?
I'll call her Jane, a lovely young lady - Mike even brought her for some of the sessions. She had her own story, parents divorced, one of them chronically ill, but most importantly similar interest in Mike's interests, scientific and video. She's also a bit of a STEM (science technology engineering and math) kind of a kid as well, but with a smile and lots more emotional availability than Mike.
As Mike's progress in school continued as did his relationship with Jane, I broached the subject of birth control, as I do with most any late adolescent who's dating, spectrum or not. Mike reverted to a typical HFA stance: He didn't think sex was necessary or appropriate at this time. He thought they could cuddle, make out maybe, but he was not at all interested in sexual contact, even though Jane was. Well that did it for me. What NT (neuro-typical) boy in his late teens (who was quite clear that he was straight) would ever pass on sex with an available, attractive, of age girlfriend. One who WANTED to have sex, but was respecting his desire to not. Only an Aspie. Only an Aspie. It fit perfectly - some, but not too much intimacy - more than many Aspies I work with. Avoidance, perhaps of the massive tactile stimulation that sexual relations entails. I was surrendering to the HFA diagnosis despite this ongoing clinical itch that something...something....but what....was different about him.
And on we went. Just a few more make up classes in the arts (not sciences!) for him to finish before HS graduation. College acceptance in the bag, he and Jane would be attending the same local school and discussed rooming together (asexually?) Maybe this began to make more sense after his parents found them in a compromised position in their den. Maybe he decided to have sex after all. Maybe there was more....
And then he casually mentioned how his older step brother sexually molested him for a couple of years when he was younger. Matter of fact. Just like that. After 18 months of therapy, there it was. The molestation had gone on for 2 years and he said he had told his folks - thought he had told me. Just another piece of data to share - true to style. No biggie. Just letting you know.
How did it start? The brother was older and demanded Mike have sexual contact with him. Not an uncommon occurrence, sad as it is. We discussed how an unequal balance of power is a way of understanding sexual abuse. That once his brother's authority over Mike was established the sexual demands increased. How did it stop? Mike simply said "no" a couple of years later. He's a strong willed kid, so I can see that. Why did he wait till now to discuss this? The brother - with whom he's understandably had a very hostile relationship since the abuse stopped, had already left home to work. All Mike wanted at this point was to live and let live - we'll see if that sticks. Not talking about abuse is common. We'll also see what other questions come up - I know I have a zillion of them.
And what of Jane? He shared with me that a week earlier he had "taken her virginity." "Taken?" I reviewed with him that she is the one who'd been waiting for him to have sex, not the other way around. He didn't "take" anything. It was offered freely and willingly.
And I realized, finally, that we weren't dealing with Autism, we were dealing with a kid who'd been sexually abused, who tried to cope with the pain, shame and isolation that children who've been sexually abused carry, and that it looked like a kid with high functioning autism. His reaction to being abused was to became rigid, controlling, angry - at one point I thought he was psychotic (viewing the chair in the room as a combination of mathematical and scientific formula.) Same kid, different history, different dynamic and different diagnostic formulation.
We discussed virginity. In his organized, intelligent and thoughtful fashion, he shared his confusion. Mike's virginity had been taken from him by a bully, a member of the family, just a few years older than he forced sexual contact. Mike had been raped. He didn't use the word, maybe didn't even see himself as a victim of rape, but that's what it was. The emotional effect for him is the same as for any victim of sexual abuse. This is why he didn't want to sleep with Jane - he feared hurting her as he had been hurt. Fearing that sex was an act of taking and not one of mutual giving. This is what fueled Mike's best coping tool - his intelligence, making him look much more Aspie. He's a smart kid - it makes perfect sense now. As we discussed these issues he teared up, beautifully, believably. He had responded to his emotional hurt by restricting his relationships with others - the better to stay safe from other emotional hurts. That's not HFA. As I thought about it, I realized that what happened to Mike caused him to react in a way that led to a classic misdiagnosis,
Mike may well have ADHD, I think it'll take a bit of time for this to be seen, given his decision to discuss his trauma. He would think, think, think to try to cope with reality. In a variety of ways that's served him well - I think he'll do great in college. But that can also look like a rigid hyper intellectual presence that is typical of HFA's.
The most important lesson we can learn from Mike would be the importance of enduring therapeutic relationships. It's been many years since managed care began its clamp down on out patient visits. I've always been very mixed about their role. A part of me hates them and their nosiness into our business (and finances!) Another part of me believes that clinicians support people's financial reality by accepting their insurance, and thus it becomes a necessary evil. I'm not prepared to take on national public health policy. As a therapist who believes strongly in the "use of self" and the value of the therapeutic relationship, what Mike has done after a year and a half of therapy makes perfect sense. He needed time. Simply. He needed time to trust. He needed time to grow, time to find some distance away from the abuse, away from the perpetrator he was forced to live with for years. He needed time to understand his own strength, his sexuality, time that Jane beautifully provided for him. He needed time to deal with the seething anger that sexual abuse survivors so often have - another symptom that is often evident in HFA kids and in his case mis-interpreted.
Towards the end of the session Mike brought up a new video game he was mastering. He played some clips from the website and pointed out that this particular game defined his experience well. It was a game in which the hero figure would suffer, repeatedly, against the evil foe. But unlike lots of the video games these setbacks didn't really end the game, they just allowed the hero to learn how to better cope, how to better address the enemy so they could survive and find whatever holy grail that game provided. It allowed Mike to symbolically play out his own journey where he could learn, master and grow. And so he will continue.
He comes from a normal suburban Atlanta family. Mom was in her second marriage, but the couple had been married for 20 years and seemed to have nothing more than their own brand of normal ups and downs of 20 years of raising kids - Mike, with HFA (and ADHD, of course, so frequently found in kids with any developmental difference) but did OK together. His sibs, older and younger, were all pursuing their individual lives. Finances were OK. No drug or alcohol problems. No "systemic" family issues which us family therapists love to ferret out.
So Mike and I began to meet and talk, the "chief complaint" being his anger, compliance with school etc. When we began to meet 1 1/2 years ago he had been suspended for his arguing, stridently, with a teacher. Over time we met weekly at first, and then as things calmed, less frequently. We discussed his academic prowess - science was really his thing. Science covered everything. Science could account for virtually every aspect of life's challenges and choices. And when science failed, math could be substituted. Yeah, Aspie - ish. It was the "ish" that continued to nag at me.
Also consistent with the diagnoses were the behavioral problems in school as well as his lack of emotional regulation. At one point had thoughts of suicide that landed him in a local psychiatric hospital. Very Aspie. Happens all the time.
We spent time reviewing his relationships with his family. Standard family therapy practice, sometimes including his parents. Lots of time was spent reviewing his relationships with his siblings, parents, communication styles. Suggestions and strategies. And of course, the (dreaded) obsession with video games.
Most of our time was spent strategizing how he could best approach the academics he did not enjoy. He's so smart that I (and his parents) felt this to be a very critical concern. While his logic was great, it seemed to fail re: the importance of passing Spanish, a requirement for his graduation. Aspie. He was very critical of certain teachers, scoffed at the uselessness of certain assignments. All the classic things these guys can get hung up on. His high level of intelligence, sometimes well engaged, sometimes not made it all the more frustrating to his parents (yes, and to me.)
We slogged through some of the computer based classes he had to take to make up incomplete work - and then, surprisingly,wonderfully, things began to turn around. His work was getting done, his attitude better (relatively, of course.) What happened?
I'll call her Jane, a lovely young lady - Mike even brought her for some of the sessions. She had her own story, parents divorced, one of them chronically ill, but most importantly similar interest in Mike's interests, scientific and video. She's also a bit of a STEM (science technology engineering and math) kind of a kid as well, but with a smile and lots more emotional availability than Mike.
As Mike's progress in school continued as did his relationship with Jane, I broached the subject of birth control, as I do with most any late adolescent who's dating, spectrum or not. Mike reverted to a typical HFA stance: He didn't think sex was necessary or appropriate at this time. He thought they could cuddle, make out maybe, but he was not at all interested in sexual contact, even though Jane was. Well that did it for me. What NT (neuro-typical) boy in his late teens (who was quite clear that he was straight) would ever pass on sex with an available, attractive, of age girlfriend. One who WANTED to have sex, but was respecting his desire to not. Only an Aspie. Only an Aspie. It fit perfectly - some, but not too much intimacy - more than many Aspies I work with. Avoidance, perhaps of the massive tactile stimulation that sexual relations entails. I was surrendering to the HFA diagnosis despite this ongoing clinical itch that something...something....but what....was different about him.
And on we went. Just a few more make up classes in the arts (not sciences!) for him to finish before HS graduation. College acceptance in the bag, he and Jane would be attending the same local school and discussed rooming together (asexually?) Maybe this began to make more sense after his parents found them in a compromised position in their den. Maybe he decided to have sex after all. Maybe there was more....
And then he casually mentioned how his older step brother sexually molested him for a couple of years when he was younger. Matter of fact. Just like that. After 18 months of therapy, there it was. The molestation had gone on for 2 years and he said he had told his folks - thought he had told me. Just another piece of data to share - true to style. No biggie. Just letting you know.
How did it start? The brother was older and demanded Mike have sexual contact with him. Not an uncommon occurrence, sad as it is. We discussed how an unequal balance of power is a way of understanding sexual abuse. That once his brother's authority over Mike was established the sexual demands increased. How did it stop? Mike simply said "no" a couple of years later. He's a strong willed kid, so I can see that. Why did he wait till now to discuss this? The brother - with whom he's understandably had a very hostile relationship since the abuse stopped, had already left home to work. All Mike wanted at this point was to live and let live - we'll see if that sticks. Not talking about abuse is common. We'll also see what other questions come up - I know I have a zillion of them.
And what of Jane? He shared with me that a week earlier he had "taken her virginity." "Taken?" I reviewed with him that she is the one who'd been waiting for him to have sex, not the other way around. He didn't "take" anything. It was offered freely and willingly.
And I realized, finally, that we weren't dealing with Autism, we were dealing with a kid who'd been sexually abused, who tried to cope with the pain, shame and isolation that children who've been sexually abused carry, and that it looked like a kid with high functioning autism. His reaction to being abused was to became rigid, controlling, angry - at one point I thought he was psychotic (viewing the chair in the room as a combination of mathematical and scientific formula.) Same kid, different history, different dynamic and different diagnostic formulation.
We discussed virginity. In his organized, intelligent and thoughtful fashion, he shared his confusion. Mike's virginity had been taken from him by a bully, a member of the family, just a few years older than he forced sexual contact. Mike had been raped. He didn't use the word, maybe didn't even see himself as a victim of rape, but that's what it was. The emotional effect for him is the same as for any victim of sexual abuse. This is why he didn't want to sleep with Jane - he feared hurting her as he had been hurt. Fearing that sex was an act of taking and not one of mutual giving. This is what fueled Mike's best coping tool - his intelligence, making him look much more Aspie. He's a smart kid - it makes perfect sense now. As we discussed these issues he teared up, beautifully, believably. He had responded to his emotional hurt by restricting his relationships with others - the better to stay safe from other emotional hurts. That's not HFA. As I thought about it, I realized that what happened to Mike caused him to react in a way that led to a classic misdiagnosis,
Mike may well have ADHD, I think it'll take a bit of time for this to be seen, given his decision to discuss his trauma. He would think, think, think to try to cope with reality. In a variety of ways that's served him well - I think he'll do great in college. But that can also look like a rigid hyper intellectual presence that is typical of HFA's.
The most important lesson we can learn from Mike would be the importance of enduring therapeutic relationships. It's been many years since managed care began its clamp down on out patient visits. I've always been very mixed about their role. A part of me hates them and their nosiness into our business (and finances!) Another part of me believes that clinicians support people's financial reality by accepting their insurance, and thus it becomes a necessary evil. I'm not prepared to take on national public health policy. As a therapist who believes strongly in the "use of self" and the value of the therapeutic relationship, what Mike has done after a year and a half of therapy makes perfect sense. He needed time. Simply. He needed time to trust. He needed time to grow, time to find some distance away from the abuse, away from the perpetrator he was forced to live with for years. He needed time to understand his own strength, his sexuality, time that Jane beautifully provided for him. He needed time to deal with the seething anger that sexual abuse survivors so often have - another symptom that is often evident in HFA kids and in his case mis-interpreted.
Towards the end of the session Mike brought up a new video game he was mastering. He played some clips from the website and pointed out that this particular game defined his experience well. It was a game in which the hero figure would suffer, repeatedly, against the evil foe. But unlike lots of the video games these setbacks didn't really end the game, they just allowed the hero to learn how to better cope, how to better address the enemy so they could survive and find whatever holy grail that game provided. It allowed Mike to symbolically play out his own journey where he could learn, master and grow. And so he will continue.
Thursday, April 10, 2014
Wounded Children
Is there anything worse than wounding a child? There are more people than we know, those with autism, other Developmental Disabilities and those who are "neuro-typical" (NT's) who have been hurt as children and their wounds can often last forever.
A mother who struggles to escape the patterns inflicted by an emotionally and physically abusive father. A young adult with High Functioning Autism who begins to perseverate on a specific type of on-line pornography who was known to have been sexually abused in that fashion prior to being adopted. An engaging, very smart NT 14 year old now being raised by relatives who was raised for his first 10 years by drug addicted parents who now copes by "not caring about anything" except his education and friends. An adult NT woman haunted by memories of her brother's sexual abuse of her. Another adult NT woman who can barely say out loud the word "sex" due to the abuse she is terrified to articulate. Every therapist has heard these stories. And these are the very overt kinds of abuse, not even including the "sub-clinical" emotional abuse that is so difficult to measure that kids endure, particularly those with DD's who can be so very challenging to manage.
The heartbreak of these wounds is how chronic they are, how deep they are and how pervasively they can effect relationships and behaviors.
Kids with DD's are 4 to 5 times more hurt by sexual and physical abuse than NT kids, but DD kids are so often unable to self report or easily influenced to not report. While we know of over 566,000 confirmed reports of abuse in 2012, we have no good way to estimate how many of these kids have developmental disabilities (those statistics aren't recorded) and given the lack of reporting, we really can't easily estimate the number of DD kids who are abused or neglected each year. If you do want to imagine, think big.
We certainly have to look at the individuals who abuse. Having a child is such a deep responsibility, and yet so common, so easy to accomplish and so taken for granted in our society where a child born into a 2 parent household is less and less frequent. Where we know the increased risk of abuse in single parent homes, either by the primary caretaker, their partners or others is sky high. And we know that those who have been abused are more likely to repeat the pattern, forcing us to mix our disdain for the abuser and compassion for the abused.
How do we support parents who are at risk of abusing their kids, particularly those with DD kids? The social policy questions are all but unanswerable: Do subsidies for childcare or food stamps increase the rates of single parenthood? Do SSI payments to families of kids with DD's somehow "enable" them? (For the record, I don't think so, but there are lots who do.) Does it help to educate teens about birth control (teen mothers are much more likely to have kids with DD's due to a variety of factors)?
Volumes can be discussed about this topic, from the macro level of social policy to the micro level of the next client I have who is hurt. All I know is that the wounds run deep, and sometimes leave scars that interfere with the core of intimacy and can take a lifetime of coping.
A mother who struggles to escape the patterns inflicted by an emotionally and physically abusive father. A young adult with High Functioning Autism who begins to perseverate on a specific type of on-line pornography who was known to have been sexually abused in that fashion prior to being adopted. An engaging, very smart NT 14 year old now being raised by relatives who was raised for his first 10 years by drug addicted parents who now copes by "not caring about anything" except his education and friends. An adult NT woman haunted by memories of her brother's sexual abuse of her. Another adult NT woman who can barely say out loud the word "sex" due to the abuse she is terrified to articulate. Every therapist has heard these stories. And these are the very overt kinds of abuse, not even including the "sub-clinical" emotional abuse that is so difficult to measure that kids endure, particularly those with DD's who can be so very challenging to manage.
The heartbreak of these wounds is how chronic they are, how deep they are and how pervasively they can effect relationships and behaviors.
Kids with DD's are 4 to 5 times more hurt by sexual and physical abuse than NT kids, but DD kids are so often unable to self report or easily influenced to not report. While we know of over 566,000 confirmed reports of abuse in 2012, we have no good way to estimate how many of these kids have developmental disabilities (those statistics aren't recorded) and given the lack of reporting, we really can't easily estimate the number of DD kids who are abused or neglected each year. If you do want to imagine, think big.
We certainly have to look at the individuals who abuse. Having a child is such a deep responsibility, and yet so common, so easy to accomplish and so taken for granted in our society where a child born into a 2 parent household is less and less frequent. Where we know the increased risk of abuse in single parent homes, either by the primary caretaker, their partners or others is sky high. And we know that those who have been abused are more likely to repeat the pattern, forcing us to mix our disdain for the abuser and compassion for the abused.
How do we support parents who are at risk of abusing their kids, particularly those with DD kids? The social policy questions are all but unanswerable: Do subsidies for childcare or food stamps increase the rates of single parenthood? Do SSI payments to families of kids with DD's somehow "enable" them? (For the record, I don't think so, but there are lots who do.) Does it help to educate teens about birth control (teen mothers are much more likely to have kids with DD's due to a variety of factors)?
Volumes can be discussed about this topic, from the macro level of social policy to the micro level of the next client I have who is hurt. All I know is that the wounds run deep, and sometimes leave scars that interfere with the core of intimacy and can take a lifetime of coping.
Wednesday, April 2, 2014
Let The (Blame) Games Begin! (or Past vs Future)
It goes without saying that families with kids with autism and other DD's are stressed. Really really stressed. Stressed to the point that it can challenge the marriage, challenge one's own sanity. If you have a kid with DD's, you know what I mean.
I've seen couples so burdened by this stress that they engage in an ongoing war of blame. This is true of those who remain married as well as those who are divorced. This can result in a great deal of mudslinging, particularly about what happened in the past. Past hurts and pain can reign supreme in relationships. And we tend to spend a lot of time looking at and reviewing what happened. It's a way of understanding, digesting at a deep level the course of the history.
Indeed, retrospection is a classic aspect to family and couples therapy. We examine the family of origin. What was the nature of the marriage in the family you came from? What was the balance of parental power in the family you came from? Were there unhealthy alignments between parent and child? How did the parents manage their own conflicts? Did they agree on parenting strategies? Were they close? Affectionate? How did you and your (ex) spouse meet? What drew you to one another? Is your marriage similar or different to that of your parents'? There are innumerable questions we ask in hindsight to understand what the patterns might have been that brought us to our current situation.
And yet......sometimes couples become mired down in what happened and it turns into a blame game that devolves into what seems a game to the death (hence my reference to Hunger Games.) It is cruel to do, hurtful to see and potentially devastating to children who witness it.
I admit, I've become drawn into the blame game as a therapist. Trying to sort out who did what when and to whom as a way of trying to create some clarity between the parties. It's hard work and often not successful. So recently, when observing a couple playing this most hurtful game, I considered something different. Let's look to the future. Slogging in the mud of yesterday is so often unproductive. What about considering what I plan to do tomorrow when we have a problem? What can I do to change the atmosphere of the relationship? How can I help create a new narrative in our communication style and how we resolve conflict?
Looking to the future is as important as looking at the past. We do learn from our history. We also benefit from creating a plan for change and monitoring how and whether that plan is working. Ed Koch, former mayor of New York City was famous for asking New Yorkers "How'm I doin'?" He wanted feedback both on what happened and used that to change how he conducted himself in the future. More of this kind of marital questioning is in order for those couples mired down in the blame game. Let the (future) games begin!
I've seen couples so burdened by this stress that they engage in an ongoing war of blame. This is true of those who remain married as well as those who are divorced. This can result in a great deal of mudslinging, particularly about what happened in the past. Past hurts and pain can reign supreme in relationships. And we tend to spend a lot of time looking at and reviewing what happened. It's a way of understanding, digesting at a deep level the course of the history.
Indeed, retrospection is a classic aspect to family and couples therapy. We examine the family of origin. What was the nature of the marriage in the family you came from? What was the balance of parental power in the family you came from? Were there unhealthy alignments between parent and child? How did the parents manage their own conflicts? Did they agree on parenting strategies? Were they close? Affectionate? How did you and your (ex) spouse meet? What drew you to one another? Is your marriage similar or different to that of your parents'? There are innumerable questions we ask in hindsight to understand what the patterns might have been that brought us to our current situation.
And yet......sometimes couples become mired down in what happened and it turns into a blame game that devolves into what seems a game to the death (hence my reference to Hunger Games.) It is cruel to do, hurtful to see and potentially devastating to children who witness it.
I admit, I've become drawn into the blame game as a therapist. Trying to sort out who did what when and to whom as a way of trying to create some clarity between the parties. It's hard work and often not successful. So recently, when observing a couple playing this most hurtful game, I considered something different. Let's look to the future. Slogging in the mud of yesterday is so often unproductive. What about considering what I plan to do tomorrow when we have a problem? What can I do to change the atmosphere of the relationship? How can I help create a new narrative in our communication style and how we resolve conflict?
Looking to the future is as important as looking at the past. We do learn from our history. We also benefit from creating a plan for change and monitoring how and whether that plan is working. Ed Koch, former mayor of New York City was famous for asking New Yorkers "How'm I doin'?" He wanted feedback both on what happened and used that to change how he conducted himself in the future. More of this kind of marital questioning is in order for those couples mired down in the blame game. Let the (future) games begin!
Thursday, March 6, 2014
Marital Sex Love and Affection and Couples with Autistic Children (or Marital Hygiene)
When I was in training with Peter Fleming, he presented on the topic of "Sex, Love and Affection" and its affect on couples. The definitions of these 3 components of relationships is pretty simple: Sex is....well you know that. Love is the feeling of connection we have to one another. The best definition of love that I have heard is the relationship I'm in that makes want to be the best "me" I can and the relationship that inspires me to grow and commit. See Romeo and Juliet for a broader description. Affection is the physical touch - non sexual - that we exchange as a way of comforting and being comforted physically. It can be as gentle as a light touch on the shoulder or as strong as a deep embrace. These are the components of a relationship that help it endure over time.
With one exception: communication. Yup, that same old boring topic that gets beat to death when discussing relationships. But Fleming notes a significant aspect of communication in the weave of sex, love and affection. He posits with great insight, I believe, that a relationship with strong communication can endure a lack of love, a lack of affection and even, gasp, a lack of sex. How? Communication bridges the challenges that we face in the lack of sex, love and affection. Surely, the early part of relationships include great amounts of all 3 of these components, as well as communication. That's how lasting relationships are built. The absence of any of these aspects does not make for a relationship that can survive the vicissitudes of life. Hard, direct, compassionate communication (these are not conflicting) is a requirement for relationships that are to survive, even if sex, love and affection are all present. Can you imagine a relationship with these 3 components without a strong foundation of communication? Hardly.
Consider, then, marriage in the context of a child with autism or any other special need. Families under these pressures struggle just to make all the appointments needed. There's medical doctors, mental health appointments, medication checks, special ed meetings, social skills groups, PT, OT, Speech, hippotherapy, athletic activities, all in the name of helping the child with special needs cope as much as possible with the realities of the world. And this doesn't include any efforts on behalf of other children not to mention the needs we have individually to care for ones self. And did I mention laundry? Dinner? Getting the dog to the vet? How about getting the oil changed in the car? What about working late on a special project?
How often do parents without special needs kids collapse into bed at night, the last thought on their mind being physical intimacy. How much more-so, then, will this be the case for parents of children with special needs?
One of the barometers (but hardly the only one) that I measure couples by is their capacity to retain their intimate lives. It's not uncommon for folks to say that they have to "schedule" private time together - most couples with children understand that. It is also common for me to interview a couple about their kid/s and stumble on the lack of intimacy their relationship has maintained. Couples who have sex every few months, once or twice a year or even less often acknowledge that this is the result of the slow wear and tear of the many challenges of being a parent presents to couples. Overwhelmingly this occurs without the benefit of the hard, honest communication that is needed in relationships. More frequently it's just bad habit. I might call it poor marital hygiene. This can be true for couples with typical children, and couples with special needs children are even more vulnerable to this. What often comes with this is a susceptibility to extra marital relationships. They can be comparatively easy - if poisonous to the marriage.
Fleming teaches that "saying the hardest thing" is a sign of good communication. Is there any better place than a marriage to communicate so actively? I will propose that couples that have learned how to communicate (which includes listening) the hardest thing have really good marital hygiene, and can survive challenges to sex, love and affection that affects many couples through the years.
With one exception: communication. Yup, that same old boring topic that gets beat to death when discussing relationships. But Fleming notes a significant aspect of communication in the weave of sex, love and affection. He posits with great insight, I believe, that a relationship with strong communication can endure a lack of love, a lack of affection and even, gasp, a lack of sex. How? Communication bridges the challenges that we face in the lack of sex, love and affection. Surely, the early part of relationships include great amounts of all 3 of these components, as well as communication. That's how lasting relationships are built. The absence of any of these aspects does not make for a relationship that can survive the vicissitudes of life. Hard, direct, compassionate communication (these are not conflicting) is a requirement for relationships that are to survive, even if sex, love and affection are all present. Can you imagine a relationship with these 3 components without a strong foundation of communication? Hardly.
Consider, then, marriage in the context of a child with autism or any other special need. Families under these pressures struggle just to make all the appointments needed. There's medical doctors, mental health appointments, medication checks, special ed meetings, social skills groups, PT, OT, Speech, hippotherapy, athletic activities, all in the name of helping the child with special needs cope as much as possible with the realities of the world. And this doesn't include any efforts on behalf of other children not to mention the needs we have individually to care for ones self. And did I mention laundry? Dinner? Getting the dog to the vet? How about getting the oil changed in the car? What about working late on a special project?
How often do parents without special needs kids collapse into bed at night, the last thought on their mind being physical intimacy. How much more-so, then, will this be the case for parents of children with special needs?
One of the barometers (but hardly the only one) that I measure couples by is their capacity to retain their intimate lives. It's not uncommon for folks to say that they have to "schedule" private time together - most couples with children understand that. It is also common for me to interview a couple about their kid/s and stumble on the lack of intimacy their relationship has maintained. Couples who have sex every few months, once or twice a year or even less often acknowledge that this is the result of the slow wear and tear of the many challenges of being a parent presents to couples. Overwhelmingly this occurs without the benefit of the hard, honest communication that is needed in relationships. More frequently it's just bad habit. I might call it poor marital hygiene. This can be true for couples with typical children, and couples with special needs children are even more vulnerable to this. What often comes with this is a susceptibility to extra marital relationships. They can be comparatively easy - if poisonous to the marriage.
Fleming teaches that "saying the hardest thing" is a sign of good communication. Is there any better place than a marriage to communicate so actively? I will propose that couples that have learned how to communicate (which includes listening) the hardest thing have really good marital hygiene, and can survive challenges to sex, love and affection that affects many couples through the years.
Wednesday, January 29, 2014
Role Models
Some folks are just born to do this stuff - I mean the parent stuff. I recently met with a teenager with developmental disabilities and the father. The teen had gotten in "trouble" at school (I use quotes as this is one of the times that I think the "trouble" the child got into was due to the school's cutting corners in addressing the child's needs) and the father impressed me. He really impressed me.
I've seen these parents before and it's so refreshing. And this is hard to accomplish given the challenges that kids with autism and other DD's can present. They're tough kids sometimes. Some are tough most all of the time with challenging behaviors, oppositionality, impulsivity, etc etc etc. Yet even with these challenges, the task of the parent is to remain an adult. As has often been said, there is no scene more silly than that of a parent arguing with a child at the child's level. That's just two kids arguing - and who wins that one? The child of course.
The father's demeanor was simple. He was an adult. No shaming "you should have known better" statements (though there might have been room for such a comment.) No angry outbursts (though the child's behaviors did result in an ER visit which was more noteworthy for the inconvenience - and parental concern than his medical condition, the child was fine.) No sarcasm. No exasperation on dad's part. Just pure, thoughtful and calm "adult." Dad discussed, he reflected, he commented, he listened. He maintained a calm voice and demeanor. Dad knew who his audience was and spoke accordingly. The result? The teen listened. Now I (and I dare say the parents) don't think this will be the last jam this teen gets into. But the teen was not turned off, shamed or embarrassed. The respect given was critical to maintaining the relationship between parent and child.
I've seen these parents before and it's so refreshing. And this is hard to accomplish given the challenges that kids with autism and other DD's can present. They're tough kids sometimes. Some are tough most all of the time with challenging behaviors, oppositionality, impulsivity, etc etc etc. Yet even with these challenges, the task of the parent is to remain an adult. As has often been said, there is no scene more silly than that of a parent arguing with a child at the child's level. That's just two kids arguing - and who wins that one? The child of course.
I learned a lot from this dad. There are lots of moms and dads (not to mention grandparents who are stepping in for moms and dads) who really do well at maintaining their "adult" sensibilities in the midst of what can be chaos.
For the rest of us....find these folks. Study them. Learn from them. That's what I do.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)